领导力提升:如何识别并克服阻碍你成长的隐性信念 Harvard Business Review 2025-11-25

发现阻碍:从好奇心开始

MURIEL WILKINS: 我认为,首先要从好奇心开始。所以你不能只想着我需要做些什么不同的事情,这正是我们大多数行动导向型的人会做的。你需要停下来思考一下,现在正在发生什么?我正在得到什么样的结果?认知失调(Cognitive Dissonance: 指当一个人同时持有两种或多种相互冲突的信念、观念、态度或价值观时所感受到的一种不舒服的心理状态)在哪里?让我来逆向工程(Reverse Engineer: 指通过分析现有产品或系统,推导出其设计原理、结构和功能的行为)一下。我正在采取哪些行为或行动,导致了当前的结果?然后,再退一步问自己,是什么样的思维模式在驱动着那种行动和行为?我正在做出哪些假设,无论是关于我需要如何领导,关于我所领导的人,还是关于我所处的环境,这些假设又驱动着我当前的行动?

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: I think there's the first place to start is to be curious. So you've got to not just go to what do I need to do differently, which is what most of us who are extremely action biased will do. You've got to take a beat and ask yourself, what is happening right now? What are the outcomes that I'm getting? Where's the dissonance? And let me reverse engineer it. What are the behaviors or actions I'm taking that are leading to the current act, to the current outcomes? And then take a step back from that and say, what is the mindset that is driving that type of action and behavior? What are the assumptions that I'm making, either about the way that I need to lead, about those who I'm leading, about the context that I'm in, that are then driving the current actions?

ALISON BEARD: Muriel,非常感谢你今天能和我们在一起。

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: Muriel, thank you so much for being with me today.

MURIEL WILKINS: 谢谢。我很高兴能来到这里。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Thank you. I'm so delighted to be here.

什么是隐性障碍?

ALISON BEARD: 我们首先来谈谈究竟什么是隐性障碍(Hidden Blocker: 阻碍个人成长和领导力提升,但自身未意识到的信念或思维模式)。它们之所以隐性,是因为人们不知道它们的存在,并且尽管有它们,人们仍然取得了很大的成功,是吗?

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: Let's first talk about what exactly a hidden blocker is. They're hidden because people don't that they're there, and they've managed to be very successful in spite of them?

MURIEL WILKINS: 是的。所以隐性障碍是你所持有的信念。信念是什么?信念是你告诉自己的叙述。它是一个故事。它是一个假设。它们之所以隐性,是因为虽然它们过去可能帮助过你,但它们已经变得如此习惯,以至于你甚至没有意识到它们仍在某些情况下运作,而实际上,在这些情况下它们可能不像过去那样有效了。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Yeah. So hidden blockers are beliefs that you hold. And what is a belief? A belief is a narrative that you tell yourself. It's a story. It's an assumption. And so the reason why they are hidden is because, while they may have helped you in the past, they have become so habitual that you're not even aware that they're still operating in situations where they actually might not be as effective as they have been for you in the past.

如何识别隐性障碍?

ALISON BEARD: 如果它不是显而易见的东西,那它是如何变得明显的呢?

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: If it is something that's not obvious, how does it become apparent?

MURIEL WILKINS: 它通常会变得明显,因为你所期望的结果与你实际经历的之间存在一些认知失调。因此,你可以通过两种方式获得线索。它可以是一个外部线索。例如,如果你曾经收到过一些反馈,你可能会觉得那个反馈与我无关,或者那不是我希望被看待的方式,或者你的团队可能没有按照你希望的方式表现。所以可能有一些外部线索表明事情没有按照你希望的方式发展,但你也可以有一些内部线索。如果你感到沮丧,如果你感到倦怠,如果你对自己在工作中的运作方式或领导方式感到不安或不适,那么这也是你应该倾听的,因为这背后可能是一个信念,一个限制性信念,或者我称之为隐性障碍,它正在阻碍你。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: It usually becomes apparent, because there's some dissonance between what you desire in terms of an outcome and what you're actually experiencing. And so you can have a cue around that in two ways. It can be an external cue. So if you've ever received some feedback, for example, and you're like, that feedback doesn't resonate with me or that's not the way I want to be seen, or your team might not be performing in the way you'd like them to perform. So there might be some external cues that things aren't going the way that you would like them, but you can also have some internal cues. If you're feeling frustration, if you're feeling burned out, if you're feeling some unease or some malaise around how you're operating at work or how you're leading, then that is also something you should be listening to that behind that, might be a belief or a limiting belief, or a hidden blocker, as I call them, that is getting in your way.

教练的视角:发现隐性障碍

ALISON BEARD: 你是一名高管教练。那么你是如何理解到许多看似能力很强、成就斐然的专业人士,其实正受这些障碍的困扰,而这些障碍阻碍了他们获得晋升,或者阻碍了他们的团队发挥最佳表现的呢?

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: And so you're an executive coach. And so how did you come to understand that lots of professionals who are seemingly high powered, high achieving, are suffering from these blockers, and it is preventing them from getting that promotion or encouraging their team to perform as well as they can?

MURIEL WILKINS: 是的。我认为,这实际上是两条并行路径,在两个层面上。第一个层面是,我发现我的客户非常注重行动,致力于实现他们的目标。所以,如果他们收到反馈,我们会很快地说:“好的,这是你要做的。”但我发现这不可持续。他们能够采取行动,改变行为,但效果是短暂的。所以我开始好奇,为什么他们即使在外表上可能很成功,却仍然会撞墙?他们可能仍然会得到晋升,但他们仍然面临着一定程度的沮丧,对自己的领导方式感到不安。这让我思考,这背后是什么?然后我发现,驱动行为的是信念。它是我们的内部操作系统。所以我看到这种情况发生在我的客户身上,坦率地说,我也看到它发生在我自己身上,我在职业上或其他方面不断遇到某些障碍,并认识到,嗯,也许我在某种程度上促成了这些障碍。这不仅仅是改变我正在做的事情,而是改变我对所做事情的看法。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Yeah. I mean, really, it was a parallel path, I think, on two levels. So the first level is, I saw with my clients that we were very action oriented in terms of moving towards the goals that they had. And so we were very quick, if they received feedback to say, OK, well here's what you're going to do. But what I found is that it wasn't sustainable. They were able to take the actions, change the behavior, but it was short lived. And so I became curious around why is it that they still keep hitting a wall, even though they might be successful on the outside. They may still get the promotion, but they were still facing a level of frustration, a level of unease with the way that they were leading. That led me to think, well, what's behind that? And I then found that, well, what's driving the behavior is the belief. It's our internal operating system. So I saw this happen with my clients, and quite frankly, I also saw it happen with myself, where I kept hitting certain walls, professionally or otherwise, and recognized that, well, maybe I'm contributing to them in some way. And it's not just about changing what I'm doing, but it's also about changing the way I think about what I'm doing.

ALISON BEARD: 所以,如果你得到的反馈是你是微观管理者(Micromanager: 指对下属工作细节过度干预和控制的管理者),那不是“好的,我如何停止微观管理”,而是“我为什么要微观管理”。

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: So it's like if you get feedback that you're a micromanager, it's not, OK, how do I stop micromanaging, it's why do I micromanage.

MURIEL WILKINS: 完全正确。是什么在驱动这种微观管理?很多时候,这基于你对你所管理的人的看法,或者你对你所做的工作的看法,或者你对自己的看法,这些看法最终导致了那种行为。有趣的是,Alison,这并不是什么新鲜事。它适用于许多其他领域。想想健康。想想减肥。人们总是说,在你改变与食物的关系之前,你必须改变你对食物的看法,这才会改变你的饮食方式等等。那么,为什么它不能应用于我们的工作方式,当然,还有我们的领导方式呢?

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Exactly. What's driving the micromanagement. Which is, a lot of times based on, well, what are you thinking about the folks that you're managing, or what are you thinking about the work that you're doing, or what are you thinking about yourself that's then leading to that behavior? And what's interesting, Alison, is this is nothing new. It's something that's applied in a lot of other domains. You think about health. You think about weight loss. People always say you've got to change your mindset around food before you can change your relationship with food, which then changes the way you eat and all the rest of it. Well, then so why can't it apply to the way that we work and certainly, the way that we lead?

最常见的七种隐性障碍

ALISON BEARD: 那么你是如何识别出人们最常遇到的障碍类型的呢?

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: So how did you go about identifying the most common types of blockers that people experience?

MURIEL WILKINS: 是的。所以我再次变得好奇,不仅是是否存在可能阻碍你的信念,我还想知道,是否有某些信念是跨越不同类型领导者的?所以我审视了我过去20年指导过的300多位领导者,并寻找证据,看看是什么可能驱动了他们的行为。我当时不确定是否会发现什么,但出乎意料的是,有七种信念浮出水面。这并不是说它们是唯一可能阻碍你的信念,但它们是我合作过的这些领导者中最常见的,顺便说一下,这些领导者在性别、人口统计学和行业方面都有所不同。所以它们在出现的地方是相当普遍的。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Yeah. So I became curious, again, around, not only are there beliefs that might get in your way, but then I wondered, are there some that cross different types of leaders? So I looked across over 300 of the leaders that I had coached over the past 20 years and looked to see what evidence there was around what might be driving their behavior. And I wasn't sure if I was going to find anything, but lo and behold, there were seven that bubbled up to the top. Now, that's not to say they are the only beliefs that might get in your way, but these were the most common ones across these leaders that I had worked with who, by the way, differed in terms of gender, in terms of demographics, in terms of sectors. So it's pretty agnostic in terms of where they showed up.

ALISON BEARD: 而且,它们在层级上也不同。这可能发生在非常初级的员工身上,也可能发生在C级高管身上。

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: And also, they differed in terms of level in the hierarchy. This can happen to someone who's very junior, as well as someone who's in the C-suite.

MURIEL WILKINS: 是的,我的意思是,我观察的大多数人至少都处于管理职位,所以他们确实领导着其他人。但问题是,当你试图大规模领导时,它们会变得更具影响力。所以,如果你在领导力发展管道中不断晋升,或者在你的职业生涯中不断进步,那么它们阻碍你的风险就越大。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Yeah, I mean, most of the folks that I looked at were, in at very least, managerial positions, so they did lead others. But what happens is they become more consequential the more that you're trying to lead at scale. So the more that you are going up through the leadership pipeline, if you will, or advancing in your profession, the more that there's a risk of them getting in the way.

ALISON BEARD: 我想让我们的听众了解这七种障碍是什么。我们不能深入探讨所有这些,但我们会探讨其中几个。这七种是——我需要参与其中,我需要立即完成,我知道我是对的,我不能犯错,如果我能做到,你也能;我不能说不,以及我不属于这里。所以“我需要立即完成”肯定引起了许多人的共鸣,尤其是在当今一切都以如此快的速度发展,我们需要结果的环境下。那么谈谈它是如何表现出来的,以及它可能造成的损害。

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: So I want to clue our listeners in to what the seven blockers are. We can't dig into all of them, but we'll dig into a few of them. So the seven are-- I need to be involved, I need it done now, I'm know I'm right, I can't make a mistake, if I can do it, so can you; I can't say no, and I don't belong here. So the I need it done now certainly resonates with many people, particularly in today's climate where everything is moving at such a fast pace, we need a result. So talk about how that manifests itself and the damage that it can cause.

隐性障碍一:我需要立即完成

MURIEL WILKINS: 是的,所以它表现出来的方式,坦率地说,可能不会以你感到“哦,天哪,我有这个信念,它正在对我造成可怕的后果”的内部线索形式表现出来,但它肯定会对其他人产生后果。它表现出来的方式是,感觉缺乏优先级。我们把所有事情都等同于既重要又紧急。感觉人们筋疲力尽,因为他们正在做各种事情,以便完成清单上的所有任务。哦,顺便说一句,它从来没有感觉任何事情是完成的。它看起来也像是经常发生变化。所以你在组织层面处于变革加速的循环中,这也会带来可怕的后果,因为组织可能没有能力或准备好如此频繁地维持这种程度的变革。所以它在外部表现出来的方式有很多种。坦率地说,唯一觉得从中受益的人是持有这种信念的领导者本身,因为他们认为自己正在提高生产力。但实际上,正在发生的是有毒生产力(Toxic Productivity: 指不惜一切代价追求生产力,导致身心俱疲、人际关系受损的过度工作状态),也就是说,当你试图不惜一切代价做事情时,这会对组织内的人员以及你建立公司能力的能力产生严重影响。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Yeah, so the way that it manifests itself, quite frankly, it may not manifest itself in terms of you feeling an internal queue of oh, my gosh, I have this belief, and it's having dire consequences on me, but it certainly has consequences on everyone else. And the way it shows up is, it feels like there's lack of prioritization. We are equating everything as important and urgent at the same time. It feels like people are burned out because they are pulling all types of things to be able to get everything on the list done. And oh, by the way, it never feels like anything is done. It also looks like there's frequent change happening. So you're on the change acceleration wheel at an organizational level, which also, has dire consequences because the organization may not be equipped or ready to sustain that level of change so frequently. So there are a number of ways that it shows up externally. And quite frankly, the only person who feels like they're benefiting from it is the leader itself who holds that belief, because they think that they are being productive. But in actuality, what's happening is toxic productivity, which is, when you're trying to do things at all costs or at any cost, which then has a severe impact on the people within your organization and your ability to build capacity within that company.

ALISON BEARD: 是的。我们将讨论如何解除这些障碍的过程。但首先,让我们深入探讨更多例子。“我能做到,所以你也应该能做到。”这真的引起了作为X世代(Generation X: 指大致出生于1965年至1980年之间的人群)的我,在与来自不同世代、以不同方式运作的人打交道时的共鸣。它也是一个功能性的问题。我来自新闻背景,而不是企业背景。谈谈如果这是我的障碍,它如何阻碍我。

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: Yeah. And we're going to talk through the process for unblocking yourself. But first, let's dig in to a few more examples. I can do it, so you should be able to too. That really resonates with me as a Gen Xer who is dealing with people from many different generations, who operate in a different way than I do. It also is a functional thing. I come from a journalism background, not a corporate one. Talk about why, if that's my blocker, it could be holding me back.

隐性障碍二:我能做到,所以你也能

MURIEL WILKINS: 是的,有趣的是,所有这些信念都源于一个好的初衷。意图是好的,我们常常认为“如果我能做到,你也能”是激励性的。如果我这个小小的我都能做到,你为什么不能做到呢?但这里的假设是,这个人所带来的与你所带来的是完全相同的,这完全与人才发展基础(Developing People 101: 指人才培养和发展领域的基本原则和入门知识)背道而驰。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Yeah, so you what's interesting, all of these beliefs come from a good place. The intent is good, and we often think about that if I can do it, so can you, is motivational. If I can do it, little old me, why can't you do it? But the assumption there is that what the person is bringing to the table is exactly what you bring to the table, which runs completely counter to Developing People 101.

ALISON BEARD: 然后他们会完全按照——

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: And then they'll do it exactly the way--

MURIEL WILKINS: 而且你会完全按照——完全正确。所以如果我们思考如何发展人才,如何在组织中领导变革,如何在组织中提升能力。第一条规则是,你必须从人们的现状出发。这甚至是一切谈判或影响的基础。因此,能够从人们的现状出发的技能和能够做到这一点的思维模式,是许多不同领域取得高效的关键。所以如果我们的出发点是“不,从我的现状出发”,这本质上就是“如果我能做到,你也能”所表达的,那么我们就会阻碍自己在许多不同领域真正发挥效用。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: And that you'll do it exactly-- exactly. So if we think about how to develop people, how to lead change in an organization, how to grow capacity, again, within an organization. The number one rule is, you've got to meet people where they are. That, even, underlies any negotiation or any influence. And so the skill of being able to meet people where they are and the mindset to be able to do that is what leads to a lot of effectiveness in so many different domains. So if our starting point is no, meet me where I am, which is, essentially, what the if I can do it, so can you says, then we're getting in our way of really being effective in a number of different areas.

隐性障碍三:我不能犯错

ALISON BEARD: 然后我想谈的第三个是害怕犯错。因为我认为,特别是当你达到一定级别时,你期望你所做的事情,以及每个人都看着你,期望你是完美的。但我也认为,在当前经济和地缘政治高度不确定,技术不断变化的时代,人们感到有些麻痹。他们肯定可能更厌恶风险,因为一步走错真的可能对他们的职业生涯产生可怕的后果。所以请谈谈你现在如何看待“我不能犯错”这种信念在你的客户身上体现出来。

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: And then the third one I just want to touch on is fear of making mistakes. Because I think, particularly, when you get to a certain level, you expect that what you're doing and that everyone sees you and looks at you and expects you to be perfect. But then I think also, in times like this of great economic and geopolitical uncertainty, with technological change, people feel a little bit paralyzed. And they definitely are maybe more risk averse, because a misstep could really have dire consequences for their career. So talk a little bit about how you see this I can't make a mistake playing out for your clients right now.

MURIEL WILKINS: 是的,绝对如此。所以“我不能犯错”这种信念确实阻碍了前进。我的客户中担任领导职位的人很清楚,他们有两项任务,特别是在领导组织时。一项任务是他们必须管理风险。是的,绝对如此。这并不是要成为一个鲁莽的犯错者。你必须管理风险。但他们的另一项任务是推动组织朝着它需要前进的战略方向发展。我们需要取得成果。我们需要能够实现你希望实现的任何指标。而“我不能犯错”往往会阻碍公式的后半部分,因为我们开始担心做出决策。我们开始担心确立立场。这可能导致过于频繁地改变方向,而不是努力坚持到底。这甚至可能导致不授权和不培养内部人才。所以它只是阻碍我们履行我们实际拥有的一些领导责任。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Yeah, absolutely. So the I can't make a mistake belief really gets in the way of being able to move forward. And what's clear with my clients who hold leadership positions is they have two mandates, particularly when they are leading organizations. One mandate is they have to manage risk. Yes, absolutely. This is not about being a reckless mistake maker. You ought to manage risk. But there are other mandate is to move the organization forward in the strategic direction that it needs to go in. We need to get results. We need to be able to deliver to whatever metrics you're looking to deliver to. The I can't make a mistake tends to hold that latter part of the formula back because we become concerned about making decisions. We become concerned about putting a stake in the ground. It can lead to changing course too often, instead of trying to follow through. It can lead to then even not delegating and building people from within. So it just holds us back from exacting some of the leadership responsibilities that we actually have.

克服障碍的动力

ALISON BEARD: 是的。在职业生涯方面,你确实指出,有障碍的人仍然可以得到晋升。他们仍然可以在组织中晋升到非常高的位置。那么对于那些可能认为自己的一些障碍是富有成效的,比如完美主义者或要求紧迫性的人来说,推动他们完成所需工作的动力是什么?

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: Yeah. And career wise, you do make the point that people with blockers can still get promoted. They can still rise very high in the organization. So for someone who maybe thinks that some of their blockers are productive, being a perfectionist or demanding urgency, what's the impetus for doing the work required to push through them?

MURIEL WILKINS: 我的意思是,总得有一个动力。改变不会仅仅因为闲着说“哦,也许今天我会做出一些改变”而发生。所以通常,要么是外部强加的一些东西。例如,很多时候,“我不能犯错”作为一个隐性信念,它会引起你的老板、你的同事、你的下属等利益相关者的很多挫败感。如果你作为领导者不想疏远或挫败你的同事或利益相关者,那么你就会决定做一些不同的事情。所以这可能是一个动力。但另一方面,同样,也可能有一个内部线索。如果它正在制造一些焦虑,如果你认识到你没有按照你需要的方式前进,你没有达到你想要的水平,或者你的组织没有足够快地前进。那么你必须质疑你在其中扮演了什么角色?你可能不需要对整个事情负责,但你肯定要对其中一部分负责,这可能受到你如何思考你的组织需要采取的行动的影响。

View/Hide Original Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: I mean, there always has to be an impetus. The change doesn't happen just from lying around and saying, oh, maybe today, I'll exact some change. So usually, it's either something from the outside that gets imposed. So a lot of times with the I can't make a mistake, as an example, for that being a hidden belief is, it causes a lot of frustration from stakeholders your boss, your peers, those who work for you. And if you as a leader do not want to alienate or frustrate your counterparts or your stakeholders, then you decide that you want to do something different. So that might be an impetus. But the other is that, again, there can be an internal queue. If it's creating some angst, if you're recognizing that you're not moving forward in the way that you need to that you're not performing at the level at which you would like, or that your organization is not moving fast enough. Then you have to question what part of that are you contributing to? You might not be responsible for the whole thing, but you certainly are responsible for one part of it, and that can be driven by how you're thinking about the actions your organization needs to take.

诊断和命名隐性信念

ALISON BEARD: 那么,如果你感觉到这些事情,无论是你的团队感到沮丧,还是你个人觉得“有些不对劲”,你如何诊断你的具体问题是什么?

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: So if you're sensing these things, either your team is frustrated or you personally are like, something is off, how do you go about diagnosing what your specific problem is?

MURIEL WILKINS: 那就是你开始命名它的时候。所以第一步实际上是揭示存在一些认知失调,然后命名导致你正在经历的这种失调的信念。所有这些都必须在你做任何不同事情之前发生。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: That's when you start to name it. So the first step is really even uncovering that there's some dissonance and then naming the belief that is contributing to the dissonance that you're experiencing. That all has to happen before you do anything differently.

ALISON BEARD: 你有没有见过人们在弄清楚它是什么时遇到困难,或者当它被指出时,他们会抵触?

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: And do you ever see people struggle to figure out what it is or if what it is is pointed out to them, they push back on it?

MURIEL WILKINS: 绝对有。因为信念本身并不是坏事。它帮助过你。它可能就是让你迄今为止取得成功的原因。但如果我们真正审视作为领导者适应性意味着什么,你必须能够打开视角(Aperture: 指观察事物的广度或开放程度),并说,有可能过去帮助我的东西现在可能不再帮助我了。那时他们才开始稍微放松一些。同时也要明白,你不需要摆脱那个信念。我的意思是,我们当然不想摆脱“我不能犯错”的信念,因为在某些时候,我们需要坚持那个信念。但同样,作为领导者要更加广阔,并能够处理你正在处理的复杂性,这将要求你利用不同的思维模式,那些在当时会有效的思维模式。所以,一旦领导者开始明白,通过探索并能够暂时把那个信念放在一边,并探索其他思维模式,一旦他们开始明白这可以成为他们的超能力,以实际应对他们所处时代的复杂性,那么他们就会认识到这是一种可以利用的资产。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Absolutely. Because the belief, in and of itself, is not bad. It has helped you. It's probably what's made you successful up until now. But if we really look at what it means to be adaptable as a leader, you've gotta be able to open up the aperture and say, there is a possibility that what has helped me may not be helping me now. And that's when they start loosening the grip a little bit. It's also understanding that you don't need to get rid of that belief. I mean, we certainly don't want to get rid of the belief of I can't make a mistake, because there are certain points in time where we need to hold on to that one. But again, being more expansive as a leader and being able to deal with the complexity that you're dealing with is going to require you to tap into different mindsets, the ones that are going to be effective for that time. So what it does is, once a leader starts understanding that by exploring and being able to put that one to the side for even a limited amount of time and exploring other mindsets, once they start understanding that that can be their superpower, to actually deal with the complexities of the times that they're in, then they recognize that it's an asset that they can leverage.

理解信念而非立即改变

ALISON BEARD: 然后我们大多数人会说:“好的,我的问题是我是一个完美主义者。我不能犯错,所以让我改变这个信念。”为什么你会有这个中间步骤,即在尝试修复它之前,更好地理解这个信念是什么?

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: And then most of us would then say, OK, my problem is that I'm a perfectionist. I can't make mistakes, so let me change that belief. Why do you have this middle step that is about better understanding what the belief is before you try to fix it?

MURIEL WILKINS: 对。所以第一步是揭示它,然后是剖析它。剖析就是,让我理解这个信念为什么会存在。在某种程度上,你正在与它成为朋友。因为正如我之前所说,它不是坏事。它只是此刻不为你服务。如果你不理解它何时为你服务,何时不为你服务,你就有更高的风险在错误的场合再次重复它。所以这个过程的一部分是理解在你生命的哪个阶段,在你的职业生涯中,在不同的情况下,它确实帮助了你,这样你就可以评估你所面临的情况,就像我们对待企业一样。你可以评估你所面临的情况,并积极主动地说,我需要将什么样的信念或思维模式带入这种特定情况,以增加我达到我期望结果的可能性?

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: That's right. So the first is you want to uncover it, then you want to unpack it. And the unpacking is, let me understand why this belief is even here. In a way, you're befriending it. Because as I said before, it's not bad. It's just not serving you in this moment. And if you can't understand when it is serving you, when it is not serving you, you have a higher risk of repeating it again in the wrong situations. So part of that process is understanding at what point in your life, in your career, in different situations, did it actually help you so that you can assess situations, Just as we do with a business. You can assess situations that you're facing and be proactive and say, what kind of belief or mindset do I need to bring into this particular situation to increase the probability that I will get to the outcomes that I desire?

ALISON BEARD: 那么现在我们可以开始修复它了吗?

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: So now can we get to fixing it?

MURIEL WILKINS: 是的。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Yes.

ALISON BEARD: 好的,太棒了。你已经揭示了它,剖析了它,现在你需要前进并改变自己,从一个认为自己不能犯错的人变成一个不同的人。这必须从真正相信自己可以改变开始。如果你一直将自己定义为完美主义者,这是你身份的一部分,你如何转变为一种不再是完美主义者的模式?

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: OK, great. So you've uncovered, you've unpacked, and now, you need to move forward and change yourself from someone who thinks they can't make mistakes to a different person. That has to start with actually just believing that you can change. If you've always identified as a perfectionist, it's part of your identity, how do you move to a mode in which you wouldn't?

信念的重构与行动

MURIEL WILKINS: Alison,你甚至使用了“改变你是谁”这个术语,这非常有趣。因为实际上,我并不认为这是改变你是谁。原因如下。我认为,这背后是人们错误地将自己的信念等同于自己。我们所有的信念都是后天习得的。它们是我们为了成功,或者为了在生命早期以及我们一生中所处的任何环境中生存或茁壮成长而学到的东西。这里的关键是它们是可塑的。它们是你可以根据自己想要的东西而改变的东西,而不是对你过去经历的反应。但这不一定会改变你作为一个人是谁。如果说有什么不同的话,它会扩展你是谁。所以当你开始从这个角度看待它时,我认为这就是导致更多开放性的思维模式,让你说:“哦,好的,是的,我可以接受另一个信念,或者我现在可以以这种方式开始工作”,这反过来又让你能够真正进入行动阶段,也就是说,如果我接受这个新信念,如果我重新构建了它,并且我从“我不能犯错”转变为“我们将尽我们所能,利用我们拥有的资源”,或者“我们将尽我们所能,利用我们拥有的信息”,那么你就可以说:“好的,那么哪些行动与此相符,能让我达到我想要的结果?”

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: So it's so interesting, Alison, that you're even using the terminology change who you are. Because actually, I don't see this as changing who you are. And here's why. I think underlying, this is people mistaken that their beliefs who they are. All of our beliefs are learned. They're what we learned in order to be successful or in order to survive or thrive in any context that we were in early on in life and as we moved through life. The key here is they're malleable. They are things that you can change according to what it is that you want, rather than react to the experiences that you had in the past. But it doesn't necessarily change who you are as a person. If anything, it expands who you are. And so when you start seeing it from that perspective, I think that that is the mindset that then leads to more openness to say, oh, OK, yes, I can pick up another belief or I can now start doing the work in this way, which then allows you to actually move into this action phase, which is, if I pick up this new belief, if I've reframed it and I've moved from I can't make a mistake to we're going to do the best that we can with the resources that we have, or we're going to do the best that we can with the information that we have, then you can say, OK, well, what actions align with that that it will allow me to get to the outcome that I want?

ALISON BEARD: 是的。还有哪些例子可以重新构建这些无效的障碍?也许我们可以讨论一下我们之前讨论过的其他一些,比如“如果我能做到,你也能”。

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: Yeah. What are some other examples of ways to reframe these unproductive blockers? So maybe we'll take some of the others that we discussed, like, if I can do it, so can you.

重构具体障碍的例子

MURIEL WILKINS: 所以如果我能为你做到——让我在这里退一步。我认为非常重要的是,正如你必须命名原始信念一样,人们也必须拥有重新构建的信念。所以我可以给出例子,但归根结底,工作是想出一个适合你的信念。所以“我能做到,你也能”的重新构建非常简单。我会从你的现状出发。这是一个不同的起点。这并不意味着你仍然不认为产出是关键,或者你不认为任务很重要。你只是采取了不同的路径来实现目标。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: So if I can do it for you-- and let me just take a step back here. I think it's very important that just as you have to name what the original belief is, it's also very important that people own what the reframe is. So I can suggest examples, but at the end of the day, the work is to say come up with one that's going to work for you. And so the I can do it, so can you, it's a very simple reframe. I will meet you where you are. It's a different starting line. Doesn't mean that you're still not holding the output as critical or you don't think the task is important. You're just taking a different path to get there.

ALISON BEARD: 是的。那“我需要立即完成”呢?

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: Yeah. And what about I need it done now?

MURIEL WILKINS: “我需要立即完成”,这是一个棘手的问题,因为你必须真正认识到也许不是——

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: I need it done now, that's a tricky one because you have to really recognize that maybe not--

ALISON BEARD: 有时候——

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: Sometimes

MURIEL WILKINS: 有时候你需要。在那些情况下,房子着火了。我需要立即完成。我需要你离开房子。但并非所有事情都是火灾。所以要明白,重新构建可以是这样的:“如果这是一个优先事项,我需要立即完成。”或者“如果它确实很紧急,我需要立即完成。”或者“如果它符合我们为本月、本年设定的目标参数,我需要立即完成。”所以围绕这个,你所规定的一条普遍规则,就产生了一个过滤器,这使得它在每种情况下都不再是普遍的。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Sometimes you do. And in those situations, the house is on fire. I need it done now. I need you to get out of the house. But not everything is a fire. And so it's understanding that the reframe can be something like, I need it done now if it's a priority. Or I need it done now, if it's actually urgent. Or I need it done now, if it falls within the parameters of what we have set as our objectives for this month, this year. So there's a filter that's created around this, what you have prescribed as a universal rule, which then turns it as not universal across every situation.

案例研究:我确信我是对的

ALISON BEARD: 是的。你能给我们举一个你合作过或遇到过的高管的例子吗?他们经历了这一过程,将一个隐性障碍转化为一个更具生产力的信念。

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: Yeah. So can you give us an example of an executive that you've worked with or encountered that has gone through this process to turn a hidden blocker into a more productive belief?

MURIEL WILKINS: 绝对可以。我最喜欢的一个例子,我经常谈论,是我合作过的一位高管,他的隐性信念或隐性障碍是:“我知道我是对的。”这其中的棘手之处在于,他实际上大部分时间都是对的。所以很多时候我们听到的是,“也许你可以听听不同的解决方案。”实际上,那些持有这种信念的人,他们有证据表明很多时候他们是对的。他们有一种不可思议的能力,能够预见未来。问题是,这在他们表现出来的方式上产生了后果。他疏远了许多利益相关者。人们真的不喜欢和他一起开会,因为他总是以自己知道答案的方式来领导。他之所以决定重新构建它或以不同的方式看待它,是因为他认识到他的工作不再仅仅是成为一个主题专家。他的工作是在那个组织中领导。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Absolutely. So one of my favorites, which I talk about, is one of the executives I worked with who, his hidden belief or hidden blocker was, I know I'm right. And what was tricky about that is, he actually was right most of the time. So a lot of times we hear, well, maybe you could hear a different solution. Actually, the folks who have that as a belief, they have evidence that a lot of times, they are right. And they have this uncanny ability to see around corners. The issue is that there was then a consequence to that in terms of the way that he demonstrated it. He was alienating a lot of his stakeholders. People really didn't like to be in meetings with him, because that's what he led with, is him knowing the answer. What led him to then decide that he wanted to reframe it or look at it differently is when he recognized that his job was no longer to just be a subject-matter expert. His job was to lead in that organization.

ALISON BEARD: 随着他们职位的晋升,很多人都会遇到这个问题。

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: And that's something that so many people struggle with as they rise through the ranks.

MURIEL WILKINS: 完全正确。所以领导不仅仅是向人们提供答案。领导还包括培养能力,让他们能够自己找到答案。这是领导的一部分,你正在建立系统。你正在培养人才。哦,顺便说一句,以一种你不会疏远所有你需要一起工作的人的方式来做,而是让他们真正保持一致。所以当他重新定义成功是什么,他想要的结果是什么时,我们就可以倒推,然后说:“好的,那么你需要什么样的信念才能达到那种成功,而不仅仅是得到答案。”他的重新构建是:“我需要引导人们找到正确的答案”,而不是“我有正确的答案”。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Exactly. And so leading was not just about feeding the answers to folks. That leading was also about building the capacity so that they could come up with the answers. That's part of leading is you're building systems. You're building people. And oh, by the way, to do it in a way where you're not alienating everyone else that you need to be able to do the work, but you're actually getting them aligned. And so when he redefined what success was, what the outcome was that he wanted, then we could work backwards and say, OK, so what is the belief that you would need to be able to reach that type of success, rather than just getting to the answer. And his reframe was, I need to guide people to the right answer, rather than I have the right answer.

ALISON BEARD: 是的,但这太慢了。所以很多人都为此挣扎。如果我这样做,当然,如果我正在编辑一篇稿件,我知道句子应该怎么写,我不会在旁边评论:“嗨,你能强调这个而不是那个吗?”我只是重写。

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: Yeah, that's just slow though. And so a lot of people struggle with that. If I do, certainly, if I'm editing a piece and I know how the sentence should read, I don't make a comment in the margins, hi, could you emphasize this instead of this? I just redo it.

MURIEL WILKINS: 这又取决于你的结果是什么。所以如果你的预期结果,你想要的结果是,我只是想尽快把这个事情搞定,那么这对你来说是有效的。但如果预期结果是,我还想培养这个人,我想让他们下次能够自己解决这个问题,那么就必须采取不同的方法,因为直接告诉他们答案是做不到的。你正在那里创造的是习得性无助(Learned Helplessness: 指个体在经历多次失败或无法控制的负面事件后,形成的认为自己无法改变现状的消极心理状态)。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: And it depends, again, on what your outcomes are. And so if your desired outcome, you're the result you want is, I'm just trying to get this out the door as quickly as possible, then that works for you. But if the desired outcome is, I also want to build talent in this person, and I want them to be able to figure this out on their own the next time around, then there has to be a different approach, because feeding them the answer is not going to do that. What you're creating there is learned helplessness.

ALISON BEARD: 对,天哪。好的,Muriel,我可能在这之后需要一些辅导课程。我以为有不同的障碍,但也许那就是我的障碍。那么如果人们同时与几个障碍作斗争,你有什么建议来解决它们呢?是逐一解决吗?还是可以同时解决多个?

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: Right Oh, goodness. OK, I might need some coaching sessions after this, Muriel. I thought there were different blockers, but maybe that's my one. So if people can struggle with several blockers at one time, what's your advice for how to tackle them? Is it one by one? Can you do multiple at once?

如何处理多个障碍?

MURIEL WILKINS: 是的,我的建议是,选择一个,这实际上是基于你如何或应该如何进行任何改变,那就是一次只选择一件事。所以我建议选择一个,选择你最有动力去解决的那个,或者可能是对你造成最即时后果并真正带来代价的那个,然后解决它。我甚至尽量避免使用“工作”这个词,而是使用“练习”。因为这是一种练习。它永无止境。我的意思是,你刚才问我,我有没有遇到过什么困难?我甚至不认为它们是困难。每次它们出现时,我都能更快地识别它们。当它们出现时,我就会想:“你又来了。我们知道该怎么做。”这就是我们想要达到的目标。它让你变得更灵活,以应对你面前的任何情况,这样你就可以在当下自我教练。你练习得越多,所需的时间就越少。你衡量的是你的纠错速度比过去快得多,而且你能够比以前更容易地进入那些情况。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Yeah, my advice is, pick one, which is really grounded in any way you can or should ever do change is pick one thing at a time. And so I would say pick one, pick the one that you're either most motivated to work on or the one, potentially, that's having the most just-in-time consequences for you and is really creating a cost, and work on that one. And I even try to hesitate using the word work, but rather, practice it. Because this is a practice. It never ends. I mean, you just asked me, are there any that I struggle with? And I don't really even think about them as struggle. Every time they pop up, I'm now able to recognize them a lot faster. And when they pop up, I'm like, there you are again. We know what to do. And that's where we want to get to. It's making yourself more nimble to deal with any situation in front of you so that you can coach yourself in the moment. And the more you practice it, the less time it takes. And what you're measuring is that your course correction is a lot faster than it was in the past, and that you are able to enter those situations with a lot more ease than you previously have.

ALISON BEARD: 所以这种练习是,信念突然出现在你的脑海中,然后你立即重新构建它。

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: So the practice is, the belief pops into your head and you reframe it right away.

MURIEL WILKINS: 这种练习是,信念突然出现在你的脑海中。你注意到它出现了。你可能甚至还没有命名它。你注意到存在认知失调。有些地方不对劲。是什么信念在驱动这种不对劲?我在做什么?是什么在驱动它?如果我想要一些不同的东西,让我重新构建那个信念,这将增加我达到我实际想要的结果的可能性。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: The practice is, the belief pops in your head. You notice that it pops up. You might not even name it just yet. You notice there's a dissonance. Something feels off. What's the belief that's driving the off. What am I doing? What's driving it? If I want something differently, let me reframe the belief that's going to increase the probability that I will get to what I actually want.

自我教练与赋能他人

ALISON BEARD: 是的。人们可以自己做这件事吗?我们不想让这成为Muriel教练的广告。但人们需要教练吗?他们需要治疗师吗?他们需要导师吗?

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: Yeah. And can people do this themselves? We don't want to make this an advertisement for Muriel coaching. But do people need a coach? Do they need therapist? Do they need a mentor?

MURIEL WILKINS: 我正在努力让自己失业。当我作为高管教练与人们一对一合作时,我衡量成功的标准是,当我们完成时,他们能够自己完成这项工作。我知道他们可以,因为他们会问我一些问题。在我开口之前,他们就会说:“我 K 已经知道我需要问自己什么了。”所以这里的关键在于你问自己的问题,因为答案已经存在了。所以是的,我绝对相信人们可以自己做这件事。他们可以在大多数情况下学会自我教练。也许不是所有情况。我们有时都需要一些额外的支持。但如果领导者能够学会自我教练,这会提高他们教练他人的能力,然后会提高他们更轻松地面对情况的能力,我的天哪,这肯定也会让其他人更容易。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: I'm trying to work myself out of a job. When I work with folks one on one as their executive coach, I measure the success that by the time we're done, they're able to do this work on themselves. And I know that they can, because they'll ask me something. And before I can even open my mouth, they'll say, I already know what I need to ask myself. So the key here is in the questions that you're asking yourself, because the answer is already there. And so yes, I absolutely believe that folks can do this for themselves. They can learn to coach themselves in most situations. Maybe not. We all need sometimes a little extra support. But if leaders can learn to coach themselves, it increases their ability to coach others, and it then increases their ability to face situations with more ease, which, my goodness, would certainly make things easier for everyone else as well.

组织层面的应用

ALISON BEARD: 人们不仅对自己的信念,而且对他们的组织、行业或团队的信念,是否有任何应用?

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: Are there any applications to beliefs that people have not just about themselves, but about their organization or their industry or their teams?

MURIEL WILKINS: 绝对有。这些问题在于,通常情况下,我们外部的事物,他们的团队、他们的组织等等,都不是你所能控制的。所以虽然我们可以坐下来重新构建它们,这可能有助于让你感觉平静一些,但你无法对此采取行动。所以我总是说从自己开始。这并不是说你要对发生的一切负全部责任,但你肯定会贡献一部分,特别是作为领导者。而且,即使你不是从行动的角度贡献,有时它只是你想要改变你体验所面临挑战的方式。我的意思是,我们谈论了现在宏观层面正在发生的不确定性。那么,体验这种不确定性有不同的方式。你确实可以控制的一件事是你如何体验任何情况,但它不是从你在那种情况下做什么开始的。它从你如何思考你在那种情况下做什么开始。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Absolutely. The issue with those is that, oftentimes, the things on the outside of us, their teams, their organization, et cetera, are not things that are in your control. And so while we can sit and reframe them, which could be helpful in just making you feel a little calmer, you can't then exact the action against it. And so I always say start with you. Not to say you hold full responsibility for whatever is happening, but you certainly contribute some of it, particularly as a leader. And if anything, even if you're not contributing to it from an action standpoint, sometimes it's just a way that you want to change the way that you're experiencing the challenges that you're facing. I mean, we talked about the uncertainty that's happening right now on a macro level. Well, there are different ways of experiencing that uncertainty. And something that you do have control over is how you experience any situation, but it doesn't start from what you do in that situation. It starts with what you think about what you do in that situation.

ALISON BEARD: 有些人看到百万个风险,另一些人看到百万个机会。

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: Where some people see a million risks, other people see a million opportunities.

MURIEL WILKINS: 完全正确。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Exactly.

ALISON BEARD: 如果你是一个团队领导,你是否可以做一些工作来帮助人们理解他们的障碍,而不是直接指出:“我看到你有这个隐性障碍”?“你总是对的,你需要改变。”

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEISON BEARD: And if you're a team leader, can you do some work to help people understand their blockers without pointing out, I see that you have this hidden blocker? And you always you're right, and you need to change.

MURIEL WILKINS: 因为我知道我对你的隐性障碍是正确的。所以绝对可以。我再次会说,你应该从自己开始。你可以首先,以身作则,展示如何完成这项工作。那么这看起来像什么呢?你在一个会议中,在你开始谈论你希望团队做什么之前,你非常清楚你的假设和信念是什么。再次,假设是另一种表达方式。这可能让你感觉更舒服。但如果你正在帮助团队中的其他人,比如说你正在与团队中的某人进行反馈会议或反馈对话,而不是直接说:“这是反馈,你需要做什么”,你可能会问他们,例如,“在你以那种方式处理情况之前,你对那种情况有什么想法?”如果你有人在会议中犹豫不决,例如,你可以问他们:“当你在那些会议中时,你有什么想法阻碍了你发言?”这然后帮助你深入了解,他们需要什么样的思维模式?然后你可以转变为:“你需要怎么想,你需要做出什么假设才能让你在那些会议中发言?”这又让他们在面对那种特定情况的不同方法方面,有了更多的选择。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Because I know I'm right about your hidden blocker. So Absolutely. Again, I would say that you ought to start with yourself. And you can number one, role model what it looks like to be able to do this work. So what does that look like? You're in a meeting and before you start talking about what you want the team to do, you make it very clear what your assumptions are and your beliefs are right. Again, assumptions is a different way of framing it. That may feel more comfortable for you. But then if you're helping others on your team before, let's say you're having a feedback session or feedback conversation with someone on your team, instead of moving directly to here's the feedback, here's what you need to do, you may want to ask them, for example, what were you thinking about that situation before you approached it in that way. If you have somebody who is hesitant to speak up in meetings, for example, can ask them, what is it that you're thinking when you're in those meetings that's getting in the way of you speaking up? And that then helps you drill down to, what is the mindset that they would need to have? You can then shift to, what would you need to think, what assumptions would you need to make to enable you to speak up in those meetings? And that, again, allows them to open up in terms of the choices that they have for different approaches in that particular situation.

总结与展望

ALISON BEARD: 假设我们所有人都开始这样做,在我们的团队中,在我们的组织中。你认为最主要的积极益处是什么?

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: Let's say all of us start to do this, in our team, in our organization. What do you see as the overarching positive benefit?

MURIEL WILKINS: 我的意思是,你看,我认为关于组织文化有很多讨论。当你思考一个组织文化时,它就是一系列集体信念。所以我认为在集体层面,如果每个人都开始审视我们正在带入的信念是什么,我们需要什么样的信念才能拥有我们想要的那种地方,那将推动组织中真正的文化变革,坦率地说,也会推动组织之外的所有变革。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: I mean, look, I think there's so much talk about organizational culture. And when you think about an organizational culture, all it is is a collective set of beliefs. And so I think at a collective level, if everyone started to check what are the beliefs that we're bringing in, what are the beliefs that we need in order to have the type of place that we want to have, that is what would then propel a real culture change in organizations and quite frankly, propels change at all, beyond organizations.

ALISON BEARD: 所以基本上,所有学会了这种重新构建的人,聚在一起讨论:“好的,有哪些信念正在集体阻碍我们?”

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: So it's basically, all of the people who have learned how to do this reframing, getting together and talking about, OK, what are the beliefs that are holding us back collectively.

MURIEL WILKINS: 完全正确。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: That's right.

ALISON BEARD: 我们如何集体改变组织对它所做事情的看法?

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: And how do we collectively change how the organization is going to think about what it does?

MURIEL WILKINS: 完全正确。我的意思是,你可以在许多不同的层面上做到这一点,无论是为你自己,你都可以在团队层面做到。我看到团队中大部分的挫败感是他们无法度过冲突阶段(Storming Stage: 指团队发展模型中,成员之间因意见分歧和角色冲突而产生紧张和摩擦的阶段),因为存在不一致的期望。那么期望是什么?期望是我们认为需要发生的事情。所以你需要统一认知(Level Set: 指在团队或组织中,确保所有成员对目标、期望或现状有共同的理解和认识),并检查这些信念,检查这些期望和假设,然后才能前进并决定它们需要是什么,以便我们能够前进。你当然可以在集体层面,在组织层面做到这一点。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: That's right. I mean, you can do this at a number of different levels, whether it's for yourself, you can do it at a team level. Most of the frustration I see on teams is they can't get past that storming stage because there are misaligned expectations. Well, what are expectations? Expectations are what we believe needs to happen. And so you need to level set and check those beliefs, check those expectations and those assumptions before you move forward and decide what they need to be in order for us to be able to move forward. And you can certainly do it at a collective level, at an organizational level.

ALISON BEARD: 好的,正如你所说,我需要从自己开始。所以下周我会给你打电话,我们开始——

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: Well, as you say, I need to start with myself. So I'm going to call you next week, and we're going to start--

MURIEL WILKINS: 随时都可以。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Anytime.

ALISON BEARD: ——揭示我最大的障碍。好的,Muriel,非常感谢你。我从这次谈话中学到了很多。我将对我的改变能力以及我能够重新构建一些限制性信念这一事实,培养更积极的思维模式。

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: --uncovering my biggest blockers. Well, Muriel, thank you so much. I've learned a lot from this conversation. And I'm going to develop a more positive mindset about my ability to change and the fact that I can reframe some of the beliefs that are limiting.

MURIEL WILKINS: 太棒了。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Terrific.

ALISON BEARD: 非常感谢你。

View/Hide Original English

ALISON BEARD: Thank you so much.

MURIEL WILKINS: 谢谢。非常愉快。

View/Hide Original English

MURIEL WILKINS: Thank you. It was delightful.

📌 文中提及的人物和组织

公司/组织: Harvard Business Review

关键字: hidden-blocker leadership-mindset organizational-culture philosophy self