---
author: TED
date: '2026-09-06'
guest: ''
layout: post.njk
source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rUhllpnYWR8
speaker: TED
tags:
  - stem-education
  - science-communication
  - hands-on-learning
  - pedagogy
title: Mark Rober 对谈 TED：CrunchLabs STEM 科学课程的缘起与动手教育理念
summary: 在前 NASA 工程师兼科普创作者 Mark Rober 与 TED 策展人的访谈中，Rober 阐述了其免费 STEM 课程 CrunchLabs 课堂版的缘起与愿景。他提出以“引申现象”和低成本动手实验颠覆传统死记硬背的教学模式，通过让学生自主探索与推导公式来激发其对科学的好奇心与直觉理解。
insight: ''
draft: true
series: ''
category: science
area: knowledge-meta
project: []
people:
  - Mark Rober
  - Whitney Pennington Rogers
companies_orgs:
  - TED
  - CrunchLabs
  - NASA
products_models:
  - CrunchLabs 课堂版
media_books: []
status: evergreen
---
<!-- chunk 1/5 -->

### 重新激发对科学的热情

大家好，TED 会员们。我是 Whitney Pennington Rogers。我是 TED 的策展人，非常兴奋今天能在这里和大家一起参加这场会员直播活动。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

Hello, TED members. I am Whitney Pennington Rogers. I'm a curator here at TED and I am so excited to be here with you today for this live member event.

</details>

好了。现在，我想请大家花点时间想一想你最喜欢的老师。也许你们当中有些人现在就是学生，不必像我一样需要去记忆深处回想，但我希望你们想一想这个人，以及那些让他们如此特别的事情：他们可能曾让你感到多么兴奋，他们是如何让你正在学习的科目变得生动起来，让你在课上想要聚精会神而不是走神发呆。我想对我们很多人来说，像这样的老师可能感觉更像是例外，而不是常态。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

All right. Now, I want to think for a moment about your favorite teacher. Maybe some of you are students right now and you don't have to pull back into the far reaches of your memory like I do, but I want you to think about this person and the things that made them so special. how excited they might have made you feel, how they made the subject they were teaching you come alive and made you want to lean in during their lessons and not zone out. I think for a lot of us, teachers like this maybe feel like the exception instead of the rule.

</details>

而在科学课上，情况可能更是如此。但如果不一定非得这样呢？如果科学课能成为孩子们迫不及待想去上的课，因为这门课能让他们开怀大笑，求着要去亲自动手尝试身边的一切呢？我们今天的嘉宾花了很多时间试图打造出正像那样的科学课。他曾是一名 NASA 工程师，是一位拥有数千万订阅者的 YouTube 现象级人物，并且毫无疑问是我们这个时代最受喜爱的科学传播者之一。这毫无疑问。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

And when it comes to science, maybe even more so. But what if that didn't have to be the case? What if science could be the class that kids cannot wait to get to because it makes them laugh and beg to try everything out there for themselves? Our guest today has spent a lot of time trying to make science lessons just like that. He's a former NASA engineer, a YouTube phenom with tens of millions of subscribers and is undoubtedly one of the most beloved science communicators of our time. There is no question about this.

</details>

今年早些时候，他登上了我们旗舰大会的 TED 讲台，分享了他迄今为止最大胆的项目——一项针对下一代问题解决者的 6000 万美元豪赌，以及一套旨在让科学成为孩子们真正想去上的课的新 STEM 课程。那场演讲自那以后成为了我们 2026 年迄今为止观看次数最多的演讲之一。他今天来到了这里，与我们分享关于那个项目的更多内容、他所做之事背后的理念，并详细解析他是如何一次又一次为全世界各个年龄段的孩子点燃对科学的热情的。请大家热烈欢迎 Mark Rober。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

Earlier this year, he took the TED stage at our flagship conference to share his boldest project yet, a $60 million bet on the next generation of problem solvers and a new STEM curriculum designed to make science the class kids actually want to be in. That talk has since become one of our most viewed talks of 2026 so far. and he's here today to share more with us about that project, the philosophy behind what he does, and break down how he sparks excitement about science again and again for kids of all ages all over the world. Please give a warm welcome to Mark Robber.

</details>

>> 大家好。大家最近怎么样？

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

>> Hello. How's everyone doing?

</details>

>> 嘿，Mark，最近怎么样？

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

>> Hey Mark, how's it going?

</details>

>> 挺好的。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

>> Good.

</details>

>> 挺好。非常感谢你今天能来这里和我们在一起。你演讲中的重磅披露是公开宣布了你为孩子们——我想大概是三到八年级——准备的免费 STEM 科学课程 CrunchLabs 课堂版。你在演讲中谈了很多关于它的内容，那是你提出的一个重要设想。是什么促使你创建了它？

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

>> Good. Thanks so much for being here with us today. The big reveal in your talk was the public announcement of your free STEM science curriculum for for kids ages I guess grades three through eight class crunch labs. Um and you talk a lot about that in the talk and that's a big a big thing that you you put forward. What what led you to create it?

</details>

### CrunchLabs 的缘起与愿景

>> 我是说，平心而论，我并没有在——整个演讲大概有 14 分钟，我讲它大概就两分钟，但整场演讲的重点是在为此做铺垫，从某种意义上说，就像是揭开我们如何把“蔬菜”藏起来、让学习科学变得有趣的帷幕，因为如果在学校里有哪门学科应该是好玩的，万不该例外的就是科学了。就像是 [嗤笑] 所以这就好比我们揭开了我们是如何做到的内幕，接着就是，好吧，既然你们理解了这“香肠”是怎么灌出来的，这就是我们在未来五年里将要制作的那种“香肠”。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

>> I mean and to be fair like I don't talk about the talk's maybe like 14 minutes. I talk about it for like two minutes, but the whole point of the talk is to lead up to that in the sense that like peeling back the curtain on how we hide the vegetables and make learning science fun because if there's any subject in school that should be fun, heaven forbid it should be science. It's like [snorts] so it's like we kind of peel back the car on how we do it and it's like okay now that you understand how the sausage is made this is the this is the kind of sausage we will be making for the next five years.

</details>

嗯，所以，这个想法的推动力其实来自于我一个朋友的孩子走进房间的时候，她当时大概上八年级。“你在科学课上学些什么呢？我只是好奇，对吧？”因为我在我的频道上做这个。她说：“哦，我们今天刚看了一段 Bill Nye 的视频。”她给我看了一张大概被复印了 10,000 次的工作纸。你知道的，每次复印都会留下复印的瑕疵痕迹。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

Um, and so, and so like the the impetus for this came actually when my one of my buddies, his his kid came into the room and she was she she was like in probably 8th grade at the time. Like, what are you learning in science? I'm just curious, right? Because I do this on my channel. And she's like, "Oh, we just watched a Bill Nye video today." She showed me a worksheet that been copied probably 10,000 times. You know, each time you copy, there's like an artifact that comes along.

</details>

>> 是的。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

>> Yeah.

</details>

我就觉得，而且我很喜欢 Bill，他是我私下的朋友，但那些视频也是在 90 年代制作的了，而这是一代在 TikTok 和 YouTube 上成长起来的孩子，要想以引人入胜的方式触达他们的大脑，需要用到不同的技巧。我当时就在想，天哪，我们应该为这一代人做点类似的事情，因为我知道，你知道的，我必须去挣得那 180 亿次观看量，因为在 YouTube 上，你可以去点击任何其他内容，对吧？所以这就好像你被算法训练出了如何把事情做得引人入胜。那就是这一切的开端。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

And I was like, and I love Bill, like he's a personal friend, but it's also those videos were made in the 90s, and this is a generation that has grown up on TikTok and YouTube, and there's like different tricks to, you know, reach their brains in engaging ways. And I'm just like, man, we we should we should do something like that for this generation because I know, you know, I've had to earn 18 billion views because on in YouTube, you could click on anything else, right? So, it's like you kind of get trained by the algorithm on how to make things engaging. And that was the start of it.

</details>

而且我认为我的超能力之一就是天真的乐观主义，每当我有了一个想法时，它看起来真的很简单。我就会说：“哦，是的，我们能做到。当然可以。”[笑声] 那不应该是个问题。实际上做起来难得多，但我总是持续保持着天真的乐观，觉得“啊，那会没事的”。所以这是一段完整的旅程。它的演变远远超出了我最初计划要做的，但很明显，这是正确的做法。这是正确的方法。这件事情必须得做，而我们就是做这件事的合适人选。所以我们正全速推进。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

And I one of my superpowers, I think, is naive optimism where it's like it seems really easy when I have an idea. I'm like, "Oh, yeah, we could do that. Sure." [laughter] That's that shouldn't be a problem. It's been so much harder, but like I'm always continuously naively optimistic that's like, "Ah, that'll be fine." So, it's been a complete journey. It's it's evolved to be way more than I was initially planning on doing, but it's so clear that this is the right way to do it. This is the right approach. It needs to be done, and we're the right people to do it. So, we're just going full steam ahead.

</details>

我很喜欢这一点。而且你说过你认为这是你将要做过的最重要的事情。我记得看你做演讲时，当你在分享这部分时，你变得有点动感情了。如果你能回想起站在舞台上的那一刻，当你喉咙哽咽时，你在想些什么呢？

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

I love that. And and you you said that it's uh you think it's the most important thing you'll ever do. And I remember watching you give the talk and you got a little emotional as you were sharing this. And if you can remember back to being on the stage, what what were you thinking about in that moment when you got really choked up?

</details>

>> 嗯，我不知道。我心里真的对老师们怀有极大的温柔眷顾。如果我现在只要讲到关于老师的事，甚至哪怕就是现在，我都会有点动容。当老师真的太难了，尤其是今天做一名老师，

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

>> Um I don't know. Like I I really do have such a soft spot in my heart for teachers. Like if I just teach him about teachers even like right now a little bit like I get a little emotional. It's like like teach it's so tough especially today to be a teacher

</details>

>> 单单是因为很多因素，而且这算得上是这个星球上最重要的工作，他们所获得的报酬却没有达到应有的水平，我们应该感到羞愧——我想我当时说过，考虑到他们所做事情的重要性，对于教师实际获得的支持，我们应该感到羞愧。是的，我不知道，我一直对弱者怀有同情之心，尤其是那些确确实实、实至名归的弱者。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

>> just because of a lot of factors and it's kind of the most important job in on the planet and so and they're not compensated as well as they like we should be ashamed I think I said that like we should be ashamed of like the support teachers actually get um for the importance of what they do and um yeah I don't know I just I've always had a soft spot in my heart for the underdog and for the especially an underdog who really really really really deserves it.

</details>

所以如果我处在一个能帮到他们的位置上，那就感觉，你知道的，除了在值得做的工作上努力工作，人生还能是什么呢？这感觉就是最值得做的工作，也是我能够产生并以最积极的方式促成改变的最大影响，因为就是从来没有人做过这样的事情。此外当我们准备发布它时，很多时候对于教育科技和这些东西来说，推广采纳是极其困难的，但老师们已经在 40% 的课堂上播放我的视频了，只不过那是果冻泳池、松鼠障碍赛和闪粉炸弹。那并不一定完全符合课程标准。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

And so if I'm in a position to help them out then it just feels like you know what is life but working hard at work worth doing and like this feels like the most worthwhile work and like you know the most impact that I can you know have and affect change in like the most positive way cuz it's just no one's done anything like this. And then when we're ready to release it too, you know, a lot of times with edte and things, adoption is so hard, but like we're already teachers already show my videos in 40% of classrooms, but it's jello pools and squirrel obstacle courses and glitter bombs. It's not necessarily totally aligned with the curriculum.

</details>

所以，好吧，让我们把所有的那些技巧拿过来，做出完全对齐并超越所有州级科学标准的内容。然后把它推向世界。到那时我只需要说一声，你知道的，我敲一下麦克风就能让 5000 万人倾听。所以我只要说，嘿，告诉你的老师，你想看这个，你想在你的班级课程里做这个，而我会直接向老师们推介，我们会在全美每个学区建立一张地图，我们要在每一个学区里拥有三名教师志愿者和三名家长志愿者。所以我们推广这套课程的方式，将是前所未有的。然后我们也会正规地走各州流程，自下而上、自上而下结合。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

So, all right, let's take all those tricks, make something that is totally aligned, exceeds all the state science standards. Um, and and and and then put it out there. And then I'll just tell, you know, I could tap a mic and get 50 million people to listen. So I'll just say, hey, if you know, tell your teacher, you want to watch this and you want you want to do this for your class curriculum and I'll sell that directly to the teachers and we'll have a map of the whole United States in every single school district and we're going to have three teacher and three parent volunteers in every single district. So like we we're going to roll this out in a way that like no one's ever been able to or done. And then we'll also go, you know, properly through the states for bottoms down, top up.

</details>

我们就是要把它推向外界，这并不是因为我在其中有利害关系，而是我们要确保它比其他任何东西好上五倍。独立人员正在进行实际的课程研究，并在课堂上与对照组进行对比。所以如果这没有好得多的话，我不想浪费我的时间或我的金钱，或者其他任何人的金钱和时间。这就是我们的假设前提。所以我们就是要不断调整它，直到它好得多，并且把这份美好免费提供给世界。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

Um, we're just gonna get this out there and and not because it's like I have skin in the game, but like we're making sure it's five times better than anything else. Like we're independent folks are like running actual like curriculum studies and versus control in a classroom. So I don't want to waste my time or my money or anyone else's money and time if this isn't way better. like that's the hypothesis. So, we're just going to tweak it until it is way better and just get this goodness out in the world for free.

</details>

### 科学兴趣的萌芽

>> 我知道很多人，尤其是正在观看我们节目的一些较年轻的会员，非常想多听听关于你和你的人生经历。因此，我很想聊聊这方面。我想大多数关注你的人都知道你有过在 NASA 和苹果担任工程师的背景，在开始从事你现在的工作之前就是如此。你会说你对科学的热爱始于何时呢？

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

>> I know a lot of folks, especially some of our younger members who are watching, are really interested to hear more about you and your journey. And so, I'd love to talk a little bit about that. Um, I think most people who follow you know that you have this background as an engineer at NASA and Apple and and that before you started doing the work that you do, when would you say that your love of science began?

</details>

我是说，打个比方，从很小的年纪起，我想我就是有这种——你知道的，我想如果这里有谁养育了不止一个孩子，我知道孩子们都是自带天生设定的，而我就是偏向数学、科学和物理方面

<details><summary>Original English</summary>

I mean like from a from an early age I think I just had a you know I think if anyone here has more than one child I know kids come pre-programmed and I just had an inclination towards kind of math and science and the physical

</details>

<!-- chunk 2/5 -->

### 早期梦想与工程之路

你知道，把遥控器拆开，嗯，还有就是想出一些很酷的点子。比如我这辈子最想做的第一份工作是当一名建筑师，但具体说是设计麦当劳的游乐区。所以我记得我的那种白纸、我的铅笔和我的尺子，我说：“好，从这里开始，海洋球池放在这里，这里会有这些管道。”我画了所有这些很酷的设计，这算是一个完整的循环时刻，因为现在我们有了 Crunch Labs，也就是我们的总部，它就像一座工程界的威利·旺卡工厂，里面有秘密通道、海绵池，还有活塞、自动弹奏的钢琴以及楼梯——一个无尽的彩虹圈楼梯，还有一个你永远赢不了的石头剪刀布机器人。所以就好像我最初想做的那份工作，最终还是得到了，只不过走了一条非常曲折迂回的路线。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
world

you

know

taking

apart

the

remote

control

um

also

just

like

coming

up

with

cool

ideas

like

the

first

job

I

ever

wanted

to

do

was

be

a

an

architect

but

specifically

designing

McDonald's

play

places.

So,

I

remember

I

my

like

white

sheet

of

paper

and

my

pencil

and

my

rule

and

I'm

like,

"Okay,

you're

going

to

start

here

and

the

ball

pit's

going

to

be

here.

There's

going

to

be

these

tubes."

Like,

I

got

all

these

cool

designs,

which

is

kind

of

full

circle

moment

because

now

we

have

Crunch

Labs,

which

is

like

our

headquarters,

which

is

like

a

Willy

Wonka

factory

for

engineering

that

has

secret

passageways

and

foam

pits

and,

you

know,

pistons

and

pianos

that

play

themselves

and

and

staircases.

It's

an

infinite

slinky

staircase

in

a

robot

you

can

play

rock

paper

scissors

against

that

you

can

never

beat.

So

it's

like

that

actually

my

first

job

I

wanted

I

eventually

got

just

in

the

very

secure

securest

route.
</details>

嗯，所以是的，然后……然后我觉得特别是当我上高中物理课时，我就觉得：“哦，这种感觉太棒了，我可以用数学和方程式预测我周围的世界，而且只有一个正确答案，不管我在哪里长大，也不管我说什么语言，你知道，如果我从楼顶扔下一块石头，我们算出的答案都会是一样的。”不仅如此，你简直可以预测未来。你可以造一个能送往火星的东西，哪怕从来没去过那里，但因为我们掌握了方程式。如果我们在距离火星9000万英里时的这一刻发射，它实际上应该能命中那个星球。如果我们以这个速度、沿着这个轨迹发射，这两个物体最终应该会相遇，然后我们可以在七分钟内从高层大气的每小时25,000英里减速到舒适的每小时6英里着陆。就像你可以预测所有这些事情，它就像一个真正灵验的水晶球，这对我来说非常有吸引力。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
Um,

so

yeah,

and

then

and

then

I

think

specifically

when

I

took

high

school

physics,

I

was

just

like,

"Oh,

this

feels

very

good

that

like

I

can

predict

the

world

around

me

with

math

and

equations

and

there's

one

right

answer

and

it

doesn't

matter

where

I

grew

up

or

what

language

I

speak,

you

know,

if

I

drop

this

rock

off

the

building,

like

we

will

all

come

up

with

the

same

answer."

And

then

not

just

that,

you

can

literally

predict

the

future.

You

can

build

something

that

you

can

send

to

Mars

that

having

never

gone

there,

it's

like,

well,

we

have

the

equations.

It

should

actually

hit

the

planet

if

we

launch

at

this

point

when

it's,

you

know,

90

m

million

 miles

away.

If

we

launch

at

this

velocity,

at

this

trajectory,

like

eventually

those

two

should

hit

and

then

we

could

get

from

the

upper

atmosphere

25,000

miles

an

hour

down

to

a

comfortable

six

miles

an

hour

to

land

in

seven

minutes.

It's

like

you

can

predict

all

of

these

things

and

that

it's

like

a

crystal

ball

that

actually

works

and

that

is

very

appealing

to

me.
</details>

>> 很多人就你的故事或你的经历提出了一些问题，大家只是对工程学感到好奇，具体来说，考虑到你在 STEM 领域能做的事情那么多，你是怎么知道工程学就是你想走的那条路的？是的，我觉得机械工程对我特别有吸引力，相比于电气工程而言，因为我喜欢能够亲眼看到、亲手创造和制造出能摸得到的物理实体。嗯，因为工程学有很多不同的方向。嗯，而且我也不知道，这就是那种事情，越深入接触，我就越觉得：“哦，我喜欢这个。”然后刚毕业我就找到了一份工作，我只是非常幸运地能去 NASA 工作。你知道，我的简历当时就混在一堆简历里，只是在正确的时间出现在了正确的地方。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> And

a

lot

of

folks

who

have

shared

some

questions

about

your

your

story

or

your

journey

uh

are

just

curious

about

engineering

specifically

like

how

did

you

know

that

that

was

the

path

when

you

think

about

all

the

things

you

could

be

in

the

STEM

world

that

this

was

where

you

wanted

to

to

go?

Yeah,

I

think

specifically

mechanical

engineering

really

appealed

to

me

versus

like

electrical

because

I

like

to

be

able

to

see

and

create

and

build

something

physical

I

can

touch.

Um

because

there's

a

lot

of

different

engineering.

Um

and

I

don't

know,

it's

just

one

of

those

things

like

the

more

I

I

I

got

into

it,

the

more

I

was

like,

"Oh,

I

like

this."

And

then

straight

out

of

school,

I

got

a

job.

I

just

got

really

lucky

to

work

at

NASA.

you

know,

my

resume

was

just

in

a

pile

of

résumés.

Right

place

at

the

right

time.
</details>

嗯，我想那句话是怎么说的来着？大概是“机遇就是准备遇上运气”之类的。当然，我是有那么点运气的。然后是的，我在 NASA 待了十年，其中有七年是在参与火星“好奇号”漫游车项目。所以我的硬件设备就在……

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
Um,

and

I

think

that

what's

the

saying?

Something

like

fortune

is

what

happened

when

preparation

meets

luck

or

something.

And

certainly

I

got

a

little

lucky.

And

yeah,

and

then

I

was

at

NASA

for

a

decade.

Seven

of

those

were

working

on

the

Mars

Curiosity

Rover.

So

my

hardware

is
</details>

### 火星车与超越人类的存在

>> 上面，在火星上。我想它目前距离我们有1.2亿英里。你可以在夜空中看到它，那个小红点，而我知道天空中的那个特定小点上，有我亲手触摸过、设计过、制造过、测试过并整合过的东西，嗯，这真的很酷。其实火星还有另一件非常酷的事情，非常有趣……

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> up

there

on

Mars.

I

think

currently

it's

120

million

miles

away.

You

can

see

it

in

the

night

sky.

the

little

red

dot

and

I

know

that

like

I

touched

and

designed

and

built

and

tested

and

integrated

something

that's

on

that

specific

dot

in

the

sky

um

is

really

cool.

Another

actually

another

really

cool

thing

about

Mars

is

really

fun
</details>

>> 那里基本没什么氧气，所以东西基本上不会分解，也不会生锈。所以在我们人类离开很久以后，在我们所有的建筑和一切都坍塌碎裂、大自然在一百万年内接管了一切之后，外星人来了，他们看到火星上的这些漫游车，只会觉得：“见鬼？这些东西从哪儿来的？”就像，搞什么？完全想不通。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> is

there's

not

really

a

lot

of

oxygen

so

things

don't

break

down

and

like

rust

basically.

So

long

after

us

humans

are

gone

and

all

of

our

structures

and

everything

has

crumbled

away

and

nature

has

just

taken

over

everything

in

a

million

years,

aliens

will

come

and

they'll

see

these

rovers

on

Mars

and

just

be

like,

"What

the

heck?

Where

did

these

come

from?"

Like

what?

I

don't

get

it.
</details>

>> 是的。你制造的这些东西在某种程度上将比你存在得更久、活得更久，而且可能比我们这通电话里的所有人都要久。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> Yeah.

You've

like

built

these

things

that

will

out

outlast

and

outlive

you

and

and

probably

all

of

us

on

this

call

in

some

way.
</details>

>> 比我们所有人以及我们建造的一切都要久，懂我意思吗？就像一百万年后它们依然会在那里，而地球上的每一座建筑都已化作尘土。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> All

of

us

and

everything

we've

built

like

you

know what

I

mean?

like

in

a

million

years

they'll

still

be

there

and

every

single

structure

on

Earth

is

crumbled

away

into

dust.
</details>

>> 所以这确实挺不可思议的。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> So

it's

like

pretty

wild.
</details>

### 教育理念：把蔬菜藏起来

>> 你知道，你把你做的事情比作有点像“把蔬菜藏起来”，对吧？就像你本质上是用闪粉之类外层去包裹那些重要的、难以下咽的东西。嗯，而且你通过幽默和奇观来做到这一点，嗯，你知道，现在你正在为人们提供一份亲自去实践这些的蓝图。但我相信很多老师在看的时候会想，你知道，“嗯，但我不是 Mark Rober，我没法像你那样做。”所以，对于那些觉得自己可能缺乏这种个性去驾驭其中某些做法的人，你会怎么说？

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> You

know,

you

liken

what

you

do

to

sort

of

like

hiding

the

vegetables,

right?

Like

you're

essentially

wrapping

like

important

hard

to

swallow

things

in

>> glitter

and

things

like

that.

Um

and

you

do

it

using

like

humor

and

spectacle

and

um

you

know,

now

you're

offering

the

blueprint

for

people

to

to

do

this

themselves.

And

I'm

I'm

sure

there

are a

lot

of

teachers

though

who

watch

and

think,

you

know,

well,

but

I'm

I'm

not

Mark

Robber

and

I

can't

do

it

the

way

that

you

do

it.

So,

like

what

would

you

say

to

people

who

feel

like

they

don't

have

the

the

personality,

I

guess,

to

pull

some

of

this

off?
</details>

>> 是的，我想说，这也是我在 TED 演讲中的核心观点，关于让视频走红的诀窍。能够让人记住的诀窍，这有点像我的表述方式，就是你必须从内心里感受到某种触动。如果你想触及别人的大脑，你必须先进入他们的心灵。你不能、你不能从这里开始。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> Yeah,

I

would

say

I

mean,

and

this

is

like

the

point

in

the

TED

talk

was

like

the

trick

to

make

a

video

go

viral.

The

trick

to

sort

of

like

remembering,

this

is

kind

of

like

how

I

framed

it,

is

like

you

just

have

to

feel

something

in

your

heart.

Like

if

you

want

to

reach

someone's

brain,

you

have

to

enter

through

the

heart.

You

can't

you

can't

start

here.
</details>

>> 这就是为什么，你知道，如果你试图说服某人放弃阴谋论之类的观点，比如某个相信地球是平的人，你不能拿出一堆事实走到他们面前，试图向他们的大脑讲道理说明为什么地球不是平的。你无法用理性去说服一个人放弃某种并非依靠理性建立起来的立场。他们之所以陷入其中，是因为他们有个朋友，并且身处一个社群，他们感受到了某种让他们觉得非常有价值的东西，所以你必须从这里开始。对我而言，那就像在 TED 演讲中引爆装满乒乓球的垃圾桶，对吧？或者是有人从我家偷了个包裹，每个人都体会过那种感受，所以，你知道，我设计了一个带有放屁喷雾的闪粉炸弹去报复他们，用四部手机录下来并上传到云端。你必须激起某种本能的反应，才能让人们记住，让人们去在乎，去带来改变。所以，我认为那是第一步。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> This

is

why,

you

know,

if

you're

trying

to

convince

someone

out

of

like

a

being

a

conspiracy

theorist

or

something,

someone

who

believes

the

earth

is

flat,

you

can't

go

to

them

with

a

list

of

facts

and

like

try

and

reach

their

brain

of

why

it's

not

flat.

Like

you

can't

reason

someone

out

of

a

position

they

didn't

reason

themselves

into.

Like

the

reason

they

got

into

that

is

they

had

a

friend

and

like

it

was

a

community

and

they're

feeling

they're

getting

something

here

that

feels

really

worthwhile

and

so

you

got

to

start

here.

And

for

me

that

is

in

the

TED

talk.

Blow

up

this

trash

can

full

of

ping

pong

balls,

right?

Or

it's

someone

stole

a

package

from

my

house

and

everyone

knows

that

feeling.

So,

I,

you

know,

engineered

a

glitter

bomb

with

fart

spray

to

get

them

back

that

records

them

on

four

phones

and

uploads

it

to

the

cloud.

Like,

you

have

to

evoke

some

kind

of

visceral

reaction

for

people

to

remember

it,

for

people

to

care,

to

affect

change.

And

so,

I

think

that's

step

one.
</details>

甚至在演讲中我还用了一种元层面的方式来呈现，我不知道有多少人领会到了这一点，但在最后当我在讲 Class Crunch Labs 时，我说：“向那些坚守在战壕里的老师们致敬，我想让你们知道援军正在赶来。”当我说到这句点睛之笔时，我非常坚决地要求 TED 允许我放音乐，不仅是在视频里，而且是在礼堂现场播放。因为这正是在展示我的观点：你如何把蔬菜藏起来，你如何让人们记住，你如何产生影响力，那就是你必须在这里感受到某种触动，而音乐有助于做到这一点。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
And

even

in

the

talk

I

did

this

like

in

a

meta

I

don't

know

how

many

people

even

picked

up

on

this

but

at

the

end

when

I

was

like

talking

about

class

crunch

labs

and

you

know

I

said

like

so

to

all

those

teachers

out

there

in

the

trenches

like

I

want

you

to

know

reinforcements

are

on

the

way

like

when

I

got

to

that

punchline

like

I

was

very

adamant

that

Ted

let

me

like

play

music

not

just

in

the

video

but

in

the

auditorium

because

it's

like

this

is

me

demonstrating

 my

point

of

how

you

hide

the

vegetables

of

how

you

get

people

to

remember

of

how

you

have

impact

is

like

you

have

to

feel

something

here

and

music

helps

with

that.
</details>

所以，你知道，如果你是一位教师，感到自己没有真正触动到孩子们，那就从这里开始，而不是从这里。并不是说只要你换一个稍微不同的词来解释，就能起作用了。在他们知道你关心他们之前，他们不在乎你懂多少，这正好说明了这一点。所以我觉得如果你从让他们知道你在乎开始，哪怕只是体现在你的努力程度和对他们的关注上，我觉得你会发现更容易从这里触及他们。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
And

so,

you

know,

if

if

if

you're

a

teacher

out

there

and

you're

feeling

like

you're

not

like

reaching

the

kids,

like

start

here,

not

here,

you're

not

it's

not

like

if

you

just

used

a

slight

different

word

to

explain

it,

you

know,

then

it's

going

to

work.

like

they

don't

they

don't

care

what

you

know

until

they

know

that

you

care

and

that

it

it

kind

of

speaks

to

that

and

so

I

think

if

you

if

you

start

them

knowing

that

you

care

even

if

it's

just

like

in

your

level

of

effort

and

like

paying

attention

to

them

like

you

will

you

will

I

think

you'll

find

it's

easier

to

reach

them

here

and

that

this
</details>

你看，这也正是 Class Crunch Labs 的精妙之处，我确实意识到人们有不同的技能和能力，对吧？无论出于什么原因，以我们教授科学的方式，我们已经解决了很大一部分动力差距的问题，而这占了教学挑战的90%。所以就好像是，让我们联手吧。我一个人做不到这一点。你不能只是在课堂上放个视频，就指望它真正把孩子们教会，但是我们可以联手。所以这就是 Class Crunch Labs 的核心意义所在：我用一段视频开场，然后由老师接手，提出引人入胜的问题，调动他们的积极性，然后我再通过视频切回来，接着再抛回给老师。这是唯一可行的方法，也是它背后的基本前提……

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
look

this

is

the

beauty

of

class

crunch

labs

too

is

like

I

do

realize

that

you

know

people

have

different

skill

sets

and

abilities

right

and

for

whatever

reason

the

way

we

teach

science,

we

have

solved

a

lot

of

that

motivation

gap,

which

is

like

90%

of

the

challenge

of

teaching.

And

so

it's

like,

let's

team

up.

Like

I

can't

do

this

on

my

own.

You

can't

just

play

a

video

in

a

class

and

expect

it

to

actually

teach

them

like,

but

let's

team

up.

So

that's

the

whole

point

of

class

crunch

labs

is

I

kick

it

off

with

a

video

and

then

the

teacher

takes

it

over

and

it's

like

asking

engaging

questions

and

like

getting

them

going

and

then

I

come

back

with

the

video

and

I

throw

it

back

to

the

teacher.

So

like

that's

the

only

way

this

could

work

and

that's

kind

of

the

premise

behind

it
</details>

>> 这样在某种程度上就会感觉像是和你一起共同执教。百分之百，它会……

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> that

it

will

it

will

feel

like

sort

of

co-eing

with

you

in

a

way.

100%

it'll
</details>

<!-- chunk 3/5 -->

感觉像是在合作。坦白讲，老师仍然——老师才是真正的主角，非常明确地说，我差不多就是在帮他们把球架好，你知道的，就类似于：“嘿，孩子们，我现在把这个引子抛出来，接下来由你们老师接手。”你知道，老师成为了全场焦点，而我只是不断在旁边为他们架球，你知道，给他们助攻。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
feel like co-eing and honestly the teacher still the teacher is the hero to be very clear and I'm kind of just like teeing it up for them you know and just like hey kids I'm gonna say this thing now your teacher's going to take it from here you know and they become the focal point and I just keep like teeing it up you know giving them an assist
</details>

>> 我很喜欢这点。你知道，在我们交谈期间你曾提到过，这一代孩子消费内容的方式已经不一样了，这不是……这已经不再是比尔·奈（Bill Nye）科学时代的那批消费者了。我想，当你思考当今的孩子处于怎样的环境时，考虑到大家如今在网上浏览内容的方式，你是否觉得相比十年前，他们对你现在创作的这类内容有了更大的胃口？

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> I love that you you know you mentioned at one point during our conversation that this is a generation of of kids who are consuming things differently it's not you It's not Bill Nye's science generation of consumers. Um, and I guess when you think about where kids are today, do you think there's a a bigger appetite for for the kind of content you're creating now than there might have been a decade ago because of how people are looking at stuff online?
</details>

### 内容创作与注意力演进

>> 是的，这是个好问题。我想说的是，[嗤笑] 我的人类大脑在单单一两代人之间并没有发生那么大的改变。我的意思是，需要经历数百甚至数千代人，我们才会发生进化。所以我觉得原始的 DNA 一直都在那里，只不过是那种能力……我想是的，那种能力，还有 YouTube 竟然存在这个事实。你知道，在我长大的那个年代，如果你想看动画片，周六就得起个大早，定好闹钟，然后周六上午在 ABC 电视台上看上两个小时。而现在，任何被发明出来的动画片，每一集都随时在一个窗口里唾手可得。所以，这就好像你眼前拥有所有的这些内容。这既是一种祝福，也是一种诅咒。这让事情变得极具挑战性。

你知道，我必须不断更新自己做事的方式来保持……你知道，观众的口味是会改变的。十年前算得上是奇观、有趣、能让你产生直观反应的东西，现在需要更强烈的刺激才行，对吧？所以这几乎成了一种军备竞赛，去不断让内容保持有趣和相关，从而让我能够激发出那种发自内心的直观反应，然后再用我想让他们记住的酷炫知识触达他们的大脑。这是一项挑战，但我很欢迎它，我觉得这真的很有趣，也让我保持了新鲜感与好奇心，你知道的。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> Yeah, it's a good question. I would say like [snorts] I mean human brains don't change that much from a single generation to a single generation. I mean it takes hundreds if not thousands of generations to like have us evolve. So I think the raw DNA was always there, but just like the ability um I think like yeah the ability the fact that YouTube even exists that you know when I grew up you'd have to wake up on Saturday if you want to see a cartoon set your alarm and you get two hours of it on like ABC on Saturday morning and now you can just like every cartoon that is ever invented every single episode is available in like a window. So, it's like you have all this content here. Um, which is a which is a blessing and a curse. It's like it's it makes it challenging. You know, I I have to constantly up up update sort of how I'm doing what I'm doing to stay, you know, the audience appetite can change and what used to be spectacle and interesting and make you have that visual reaction 10 years ago like it takes more now, right? So it is this almost like arms race of of keeping the content interesting and relevant um such that I can evoke that visceral reaction and then reach the brain with like the cool thing I want them to remember. But I it's a challenge but it's one I welcome and I think it's really fun and it keeps it fresh and interesting for me you know
</details>

>> 当然，外界也一直存在关于屏幕、孩子以及注意力的争论，而你显然……

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> and of course there's like a debate you know that's happening out there about screens and kids and attention and of course you're
</details>

>> ……在这个星球上最擅长在屏幕上吸引人们、尤其是孩子们注意力的人之一。所以当把你所做的工作放进去考量时，你究竟是怎么想的？你如何看待自己在那场讨论中所扮演的角色？而且……

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> most successful people on the planet at capturing uh people especially kids attentions on screens. So how do you think I guess when you when you factor the work you're doing into it? How do you think about the the role you play in in that conversation? And and
</details>

### 从震撼到动手实践的科学课

>> 是的，我认为这其中一个很重要的部分其实在于……这也是我们从他们正在开展的这些研究中获得的最早反馈之一。我在演讲中只简要提及的一个核心部分是：我们有视频，有老师引导他们，但同时还有这些亲自动手的实践活动。在活动中你实际上就像……比如以动能为例，或者实际上是以势能为例。这是一个非常有趣的例子。

你会搭建一个小小的塔，然后，你知道有时在湖边看到的那种水上气垫弹跳包（water blob）吗？有人跳上去，另一个人就会被弹飞上天。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> yeah, I think an important part about it actually is that um and one of the early feedbacks we've got from these studies that they're doing. A big part that I I just briefly touched on the talk is we have the videos, we have the teacher leading them, but there's these hands-on activities where you're actually like say for example for kinetic energy, actually for potential energy. This is a really fun one.

You build a little a little tower and then you know those water blobs that like you see sometimes at lake where someone jumps on and then someone goes flying.
</details>

>> 那么对于势能，你知道……好吧，我们其实不会直接说出这点，但我们是以这个作为引申现象（anchoring phenomenon）的课程开始的。所以你会觉得那很有意思。我们向大家展示人被弹飞上天，展示一辆汽车冲下来、碰撞测试假人飞出去，所有这些视觉画面来吸引你。但在你的教室里，你会拿到一个……你会拿到一个类似密封袋的东西，制作你自己的弹跳气垫，搭建你自己的小塔，然后你放一个小假人，让它飞出去。我们不会告诉你势能的公式，我在这里先说出来，也就是质量乘以重力乘以高度，mgh。你只是开始往下扔不同的东西。然后你开始注意到，只有两样东西会影响你的假人被弹飞得多高：

你把往下扔的物体提得越高，似乎就会产生影响；而且如果在同样的高度，物体越重，也似乎会产生影响并把你的假人弹飞。所以你差不多就像史酷比（Scooby-Doo）破案一样，自己推导出了这个公式，甚至不需要我们提前告诉你。这样你就对它有了一种直觉认知，这比光是死记硬背一个公式要有价值得多。

但真正有趣的是，那个飞出去的小人，就是这个小小的碰撞测试假人。那些用来测量受到多大重力加速度的力传感器可能会非常昂贵。因此我给玩具工程师们的限制条件——你知道，那些拥有工程学学位的敏锐产品设计师——那就是对于一个教室来说，它的成本不能是 10 美元，也不能是 5 美元，必须是零美元。它必须完全由老师们随手扔在教室周围的东西，或者你在垃圾桶里能找到的东西做成。

所以对于动能，我们制作了这些小车，它们就是一张卡片、两个大头夹（binder clips），然后像苏打水瓶盖穿个洞当成轮子。所以孩子们针对每一项工程或每一项原理、每一项科学对照所做的这些动手实践活动，才是真正产生大量学习成效的地方。再次强调，我们在这里进行引导。当你的科学……当你的气垫假人飞出去时，就像是：“天哪，你看到我的了吗？看我的飞得多高！”突然之间，他们兴奋起来了。他们全情投入，互相展示，而不是坐在教室里，任由老师像个高高在上的权威学者（sage on the stage），嘴里念着“势能等于质量乘以重力乘以高度，请把这个背下来”，对吧？

你是从相反的方向开始的。你先用“哇哦”的震撼开场，然后我们再给你揭示“如何做到的”。但你必须先从打动人心的那部分开始。所以关键就在于，这绝不仅仅是往后一坐，听我告诉你势能是 mgh。而更像是我把问题抛出来。那个势能单元里的引申现象就是：“等等，为什么？等一下，你看，倒回去。把那段重放一遍。为什么那个孩子这一次飞到了这个高度，但下一次却飞得高得多？到底是怎么回事？”对吧？然后孩子们就自己一步步推导出答案，我们从来都不填鸭式喂食。每一节课，他们都会离那个答案更近一点。

这差不多把科学教育彻底颠倒过来了。甚至这都不是我们发明的。像 OpenSciEd 就是一个绝佳的例子，他们在 2019 年左右率先开创了这种模式。他们做得很棒，向大家证明了：如果你采用这种方式，而不是像我说的让学者在讲台上念“这是正确答案，背下来吧”，你能把科学教得多好，能被记住的内容多得多，学习过程又能变得多么令人兴奋。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> Well for potential energy you know the higher you well we actually don't say this but we we started out with this lesson that's the anchoring phenomenon. So you're like that is interesting. We're showing people flying. We show a car go down and like a crash test dummy go flying like all these visual things to get you hooked. But then in your classroom, you get a um you get like a Ziploc bag, you make your own blob and you make your own little tower and and then you have a little guy that goes flying and and we don't tell you the equation for potential energy, which is I'll say it here, which is mass times gravity times height, mgh. You just start dropping different things. And what you start to notice is that only two things affect how your guy goes flying. the higher you raise the thing that you're dropping that somehow seems to have an effect. And also if it's same height but heavier also seems to have effect and send your guy. So you're kind of like Scooby-Dooing your way to this equation without us even giving you. So you get like an intuition for it which is much more valuable than just memorizing an equation. But what's really fun is like the guy that goes flying, it's this little crash test dummy. And these can be really expensive that like force sensors to measure how much GeForce. And so the constraint I've given the toy engineers, you know, these product designers with engineering degrees is like it can't for a classroom, it can't cost $10, it can't cost $5, it has to cost zero dollars. literally has to be made from just stuff teachers have lying around the classroom or you'd find in the trash can. And so for kinetic energy, we build these little cards, which are note card and and two, you know, binder clips and then like the tops of a um of like a soda bottle are the wheels that you poke a hole through. Um, and that and like so these hands-on activities that the kids are doing for each for each, you know, engineering or each principal, each science control are really where a lot of the learning is coming. Again, we're tacking it here. When your science when your blob guy goes flying like, "Oh my gosh, did you see mine? Look how high mine went." Suddenly, they're stoked. They're engaging. They're showing each other versus like sitting in a classroom and a teacher just sage on the stage being like potential energy is mass times gravity times height. Please memorize this. Right? You start the other way around. You start with the wow and then and then we give you the how. But you got to start with the part that engages your heart first. So that's the point is it's not just like sit back and listen to me tell you potential energies mgh. It's more like I tee up the problem. The anchoring phenomenon for that unit in potential energy is like, wait, why? Wait a second. Look, go back. Play that back. Why did why did he go that the the kid go this high one time, but then the next time he went way higher? The heck's going on there? Right? And then the kids scooby-Doo their way to the answer, and we're never speedoon feeding. Each lesson, they get a little bit closer to that answer. It's it's kind of turning science education on its head. And we didn't even invent that. like open sed is a great example of a they kind of pioneered this in like 2019 like so they've done a great job um of like just showing how how much better you can teach science how much more can be remembered how much more exciting it could be if you do it this way versus just like I said sage on a stage here's the right answer memorize it
</details>

>> 或者甚至是屏幕上的人单向对你讲授……

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> or even just person on screen who's telling you you're in a lot
</details>

### 开源课程与无阻力普及

>> 屏幕上的人，关键在于那确实非常吸引人，而且非常有……但同时，到目前为止，该试点项目近一半的下载量都来自在家自学，那些为了让过程更有吸引力而进行家庭教育的人群。但即便如此，他们是在屏幕上看到了内容，但紧接着他们拿过去并在现实中即时动手操作，而不仅仅是在屏幕上产生互动。我认为你不能忽视这一点。

我和萨尔·汗（Sal Khan）是非常要好的朋友，你知道，就是创办可汗学院的那位，显然和 TED 也非常有渊源。他也提到过这一点，比如你知道，我们未来可能会以某种方式展开合作。我们也是一种“积极兼容并包（yes and）”的态度，这就是为什么我们在告诉所有人，他们都可以使用我们的课程。如果其他人在做课程体系，他们应该来 CrunchLabs。我们会向他们展示我们在做什么，我们会分享心得。这是一件“水涨船高”的事情。我们希望这套方案能适用于家庭教育、特许学校、私立学校、第一类（Title I）资助学校，适用于一切学校。

这是一种全方位覆盖的方法，而这也是我们为什么将它完全免费的原因——因为一旦你收哪怕一美元，就会制造出这种阻力。所以我们只是想创造出这种善意。如果有的人……甚至有的人对课程收费，如果他们想在自己的收费体系中使用我们的课程，没关系，也许他们只需支付一笔授权费，捐赠给我们这个名为 crunchlabs.org 的非营利组织。但是，对大家来说，这是……

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> person on screen the thing is it's very engaging ing and it's very like but also like uh almost half of the downloads so far of the pilot has been homeschool um uh folks who do homeschooling to make it engaging. So but even then they are seeing it on the screen but then they are taking it and they're doing stuff in real time. It's not just engaging on a screen. Um I I think you can't ignore that. And I'm really good friends with Sal Khan, you know, who does Khan Academy. um obviously very connected to Ted and you know and he's he's mentioned this like you know we'll probably partner up in some way. We are a yes and situation too like that's why we're telling everyone they can use our curriculum. If other people are doing curriculum they should come to Crunch Labs. We'll show them what we're doing. We'll share notes. This is a rising tide you know raises all boat situation. We want this to work for home school, charter school, private school, title one schools, like everything. This is a shotgun approach and that's why we're making it free is because as soon as you charge a dollar it creates this friction. So we just want to create this goodness and if people even there's people who charge for curriculum uh you know and if they want to use our curriculum in theirs and charge for it fine you know maybe they have to pay a license fee to donate to our nonprofit which is crunchlabs.org But like everyone this is
</details>

<!-- chunk 4/5 -->

开源，任何人都能用这个，你懂我的意思吧，我们唯一的目的就是覆盖面和影响力，绝不可能从中赚哪怕一分钱。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
open source like anyone can use this you know what I mean like we don't have our only goal is just reach and impact there's no world where we make any money off this.
</details>

>> 是的。我们这里有一个来自 Shendy S 的提问，想了解这个覆盖面究竟能延伸多远，想知道是否有意向和机会，在未来某个时刻让美国以外的人群也能接触到这些。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> Yeah. Well, I mean, we have a question from Shendy S about, you know, how far this reach goes, you know, wondering if there's interest and opportunity in making this accessible to people who who are outside of the US at some point. And, you know,
</details>

>> 百分之百。那就是最终目标。我们非常擅长一步一个脚印，先学会爬再走，先学会走再跑。我们的很多下载资源都是免费的。你可以访问 crosscrunchlabs.org 下载所有的课程资料。它们是可编辑的。哪怕是课程本身，也不是像 PDF 那样固定死。我们把它放在 Google Docs 里。所以你可以拿去复制粘贴，随意修改，完全根据你的需要量身定制。最终我们肯定会这样做的，一旦我们在美国把这套模式彻底搞透、完全摸索清楚，那么接下来把这套体系推广到全球就只是一个规模化的问题了。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> 100%. That is the ultimate goal. We we're very good at walking, you know, crawling before we walk, walking before we run. Um, a lot of our downloads, it's free. You can go to crosscrunchlabs.org and you can download all the curriculum. They're editable. So like even the curriculum, it's not like a PDF. We put it in Google Docs. So you could take that and you could copy and paste it, you could change it and make it whatever you want to make it exactly what you want. Um and eventually we will, you know, once we nail it in the US and like have it figured out, then yeah, it is a it's a matter of of scaling that worldwide.
</details>

而且在美国有科学课程标准。我认为目前也有一些国家开始采纳我们的科学标准，这让事情变得更容易了，但你总得从某个地方开始，因为目前各个国家的标准确实存在细微差异。我们不会试图做出一套适用于所有情况的大一统东西，而是先针对我们自己的标准来做。我们明确把握了科学标准，并且知道其中 95% 的内容对其他国家来说都是相当适用的，之后根据不同国家的需求，我们完全可以在需要时进行微调。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
And you know, I think there are science standards in the US. I think there are another a number of countries who are starting to adopt our science standards um and that makes it easier but you know you got to start somewhere because currently different countries do have like slightly different standards instead of trying to make something for everything. We'll make it for ours. We know we signed standards and we know 95% of that will be pretty applicable to others but then you know country by country we can slightly tweak it as needed.
</details>

### 人工智能与科学教育的未来

着眼于未来的走向，不仅对 Crunch Labs 而言，对整个科学教育（特别是在线科学教育）也是如此。如你所知，现在的很多讨论最终都绕不开人工智能，以及它是如何发挥作用的。对你来说，当思考你所从事的工作时，如果往后看 20 年，届时我们甚至在今天就已经有了 AI 家教和 VR 课堂，这一切会如何改变像你这样的人或老师在整个体系中的角色定位？

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
Well, I think thinking about just sort of the future and where things head um not just for for Crunch Labs, but in for science education in general, especially online. um you know everyone of course like so many conversations all roads lead to artificial intelligence and how that factors in and what like for you when you think about the work you do if you're thinking you know 20 years ahead when we have and even today we have AI tutors and VR classrooms all of that like what is how does that change what a human like you or a teacher looks like in in that equation?
</details>

>> 问得好。我觉得，我手里这块玻璃和金属制成的东西，我只要用大拇指以某种特定的方式去触碰它，就能得到地球上任何问题的答案，一个非常棒的答案。任何我可能问出的问题，即使它对我个人、我的输入信息以及我的处境非常具体，我都能得到一个很好的答案。因此，真正的技能变成了提出问题、提出正确的问题，甚至是能否提出一个问题本身。换句话说，就是好奇心。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> Yeah, it's a good question. I mean, I think as you get I mean, I I have this piece of glass and metal here that I can use my thumbs to touch in a very specific way and get an answer, a very good answer to any question on Earth. Any question I could potentially ask, even if it's very personal to me and my inputs in my world, like I can get a a very good answer. And so the real skill becomes asking the question, the right question or even asking a question period. In other words, curiosity.
</details>

我认为随着 AI 变得越来越普及，那些能够激发好奇心、能够触及内心的东西会变得比以往任何时候都更加重要。在我看来，AI 可以成为一个极好的工具。我非常喜欢一个例子，前几天我还在想：哪怕是在教室里，如果他们配备了电脑——有些教室确实有电脑——就可能会出现这样一种场景，里面有一个 AI Mark Rober，或者深受大家喜爱的 Crunch Labs 玩具工程师 AI BAM。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
And I think as AI becomes more and more like things that inspire curiosity and and that reach here become more important than ever. Um, and I I see it I think AI could be a great tool. I mean there's one example which I really love. I was thinking about the other day where it's like even in a classroom if they have you know some some classrooms do have computers there there could be a situation where there's like an AI Mark Robber or AI BAM who's also is one of our toy engineers at Crunch Labs that everyone loves
</details>

>> 她或者我，就像是在对学生说：“好了，为这个目标设计你们的投石机吧，把它设计出来，然后展示给 AI Mark Rober 看。”接着由 AI 版的我来看，并评价道：“噢，做得很棒，但你的能量来源在哪里？你可能需要重新检查一下那里。”然后他们回去修改，改完再拿给我看。我说：“太棒了，简直绝了。举手告诉你的老师，你准备好了。”

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> where her or I it's like all right design your catapult you know for this potential potential like design it and then show it to AI Mark Rover you know and then I look at it and it's an AI version of It's like, "Oo, that's really good, but what where's your energy source? You might want to relook at that." And then they go back and then they show it to me again. I'm like, "I love that. That's so good. Raise your hand. Tell your teacher you're ready."
</details>

所以这就好比我真的在辅导每个学生，我或者 Bam 或其他人正在跟他们一对一协作，同时现场还有老师。但我认为你永远都需要人的要素存在。即便有了那种模拟的人性化要素，如果纯粹只是让一个机器人走进来教你东西，我认为那是在对抗数百万年的人类进化史，那种方式永远不可能真正起作用。所以问题就在于，你该如何将两者结合，如何做到扬长避短？我认为把 AI 视作洪水猛兽、全盘排斥是不可取的。同样，完全让机器人去代劳所有事情也不对。那么，如何实现两全其美？如何将它们以一种能够最大化发挥成效的方式结合起来？我觉得这方面会涌现出很多绝妙的想法。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
So, it's like I'm actually kind of like tutoring each each, you know, me or Bam or someone is like working with them. And then there's the teacher. But I think you I think you'll always need a human element there. Even if it's like that and it's like a simulated human element, just like a robot coming in and teaching you something, I I think you're fighting against a couple million years of evolution there that like that's never really going to do it. So, it's like how do you combine how do you make the best out of it? I don't think it's the right answer to be like isue everything AI and be like absolutely not. No, I don't think it's the right answer to just a robot should be doing all of these things. So, it's like what's the best of both worlds? How do you combine those in a way that's like um that maximizes the impact? And I I think there's going to be some great ideas there.
</details>

是的，我认为这非常强大。另一个很好的例子就是，我们在 Class Crunch Labs 所做的就像是提供新鲜食材，而你可以用这些新鲜的原材料做出不同的饭菜。因此，一位老师可以说：“看，我有 17 名学生，其中半数有这种学习障碍。我们已经讲过了这个主题和那个主题，他们在这方面比较吃力，在那方面掌握得很好。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
Yeah, I think there's really powerful, you know, another good example is like what we're making with Class Crunch Labs is the fresh ingredients, you know, but you can you can make different meals with those fresh raw ingredients. So a teacher could be like, "Look, I have 17 students. You know, half of them have this learning disability. Um, we've already covered this topic and this topic. They struggled with this. They nailed this.
</details>

>> 拿 Class Crunch Labs 的原料来为我定制下一个单元的内容。”对吧？它就会非常擅长调配所有的素材，梳理出正好切合你需求的内容。但你必须从好的东西开始输入，输入必须优质，才能得到高质量的产出。所以我认为这又是一个极好的应用场景，AI 在这方面会大显身手。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> Take the cross climbs ingredient this next unit and customize it for me." Right? And it would be really good at moving all the ingredients. Okay. This is this is going to speak just to what you need. But you got to start with something good. the input has to be good to get a a quality output. And so I I I see like that's another really great use case where AI would be awesome with this.
</details>

>> 这更像……是的，关键似乎就是如何兼顾两者。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> It's it's more Yes. And it seems like just how can you do both?
</details>

>> 没错。是的。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> Yeah. Yeah.
</details>

### 来自孩子们的提问：太空与发明

>> 好吧，Mark，我们收到了孩子们提出的一些有趣的问题，他们要么是会员的子女，要么是在成年之前自己就以某种方式成为了 TED 会员。我要和你分享其中的几个。通常大家在提问时不会写上自己的年龄，但这次很多人都写了。八岁的 Winston K 问，你未来是否有打算去太空走一趟？你认为到 2040 年，太空旅行会普及到什么程度？

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> Well, Mark, we have some fun questions from from kids um who are either of members or somehow became TED members themselves before before they um became adults. Um and so I'm going to share some of those with you. Um, usually people don't put their age when they share a question, but we have a lot of that. So, Winston K, who's eight, um, asked if you plan to visit space one day and how common will do you think space travel will be by 2040?
</details>

>> Winston，多棒的提问。到哪一年来着？

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> Winston. What a great By when?
</details>

>> 2040 年。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> 2040.
</details>

>> 那很快了。没多久了。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> Which is soon. It's soon.
</details>

>> 是的，2040 年。我认为我们肯定已经登上火星了。我刚刚去过……我不知道自己能透露多少，但我可以说，三天前我去了 SpaceX，商讨未来一到两年内可能开展的项目，如果一切顺利的话。所以，太空绝对在我不久的将来。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> Yeah, 2040. I I think we'll definitely be on Mars. Um, I was just at I don't know if I'm allowed how much I'm allowed to say, but I will say three days ago I was at SpaceX um talking about something potentially in the next year or two. Um, if everything goes right. So, space is definitely in my near future.
</details>

另外还有一些，天哪，未来一两年里有太多酷炫的事情可以说了。我将要去往一些非常非常有意思的地方。而对于其他人来说，太空旅行——如果你走太空航线的话，大概 45 分钟就能从洛杉矶抵达澳大利亚。所以我认为它会变得普遍得多。我认为每个人都会……我是说 Winston，Winston 只有八岁，对吧？

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
Um, uh, also there's some man, there's so much cool stuff to say in the next year or two. I'm going to be going to some very very interesting places. Uh and and and for everyone else, space travel, I mean, you could get to Australia from Los Angeles in like 45 minutes if you travel to space. Um so I I think it will become much more common. I think I think for everyone I mean Winston, it was Winston's eight years old, right?
</details>

>> Winston，你肯定会去太空的。这一点我完全可以说。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> Winston for sure you will go to space. I'll say that much.
</details>

>> 这太令人兴奋了。大家请持续关注 Mark Rober，获取更多关于未来动向的信息。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> It's exciting. there. I feel like there's a stay. Keep watching Mark Robber for more information about like where what's [laughter] on the horizon there.
</details>

>> 接下来会有一些很酷的机会，大概就是通过我去往一些相当不可思议的地方，来激起大家对科学教育的热情。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> There's some cool opportunities coming up that kind of revolve around getting people excited about science education by me going to from some pretty wild places.
</details>

>> 好的。太棒了。我们很期待。Rory 没有透露年龄，但表示自己是个孩子，问：“你做过的东西里，最喜欢的是哪一件？你又是怎么想到接下来要做什么的？”

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> All right. All right. We'll take it. Um, so Rory, who didn't share their age, but said that they are a kid, um, asked, "What is your favorite thing that you've ever made, and how do you think of what to make next?"
</details>

>> 怎么想到接下来做什么？最喜欢做过的东西，这很难选。我们刚刚做了一个机器人守门员，C罗都没法攻破它的球门。那是一个以每小时 40 英里的速度来回移动的足球守门员，并且我们对射门轨迹进行追踪。那真的太好玩了。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> How do you think what to next? I mean, favorite thing I've ever made. That's hard. We just did a robot goalie that that Ronaldo couldn't score on, like a a soccer goalie that moved back and forth at 40 miles an hour, and then we tracked the shot. Really, that was really fun.
</details>

至于接下来做什么，我认为这就是做工程师的美妙之处，灵感不是凭空冒出来的。我的意思是，几乎从来都不是——当然，在我独自单干的时候是这样，现在我们会特意组织头脑风暴纯粹是因为和团队一起做挺好玩的——但灵感几乎从来不是来自于“我今天要在那里坐上一个小时，然后开始头脑风暴想点子”，绝不是这样的。比如，我想出松鼠障碍赛，是因为当时松鼠在偷吃我的鸟食，大多数人可能只会抱怨一句“倒霉透了，松鼠把我的鸟食全偷光了”。但我看到的是一个

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
um the uh you know as far as what to make next. I think that's the beauty of being engineer is like it's not like oh the ideas come I mean almost never certainly when I was doing it on my own now we'll do it just because it's kind of fun with the team but like they almost never come from like I'm going to sit down today for an hour and I will brainstorm ideas never like I came up with a squirrel obstacle course when squirrels were stealing my bird seed and [clears throat] most people would just be like gosh darn it steals are, you know, squirrels are stealing all my bird seed. But I'm I saw an
</details>

<!-- chunk 5/5 -->

机会。当时我就想，等等，如果我真的给它们设一个由八部分组成的忍者勇士障碍赛，让它们凭真本事去赚呢？鸟儿们可以随心所欲地飞来飞去。松鼠想吃，唯一的办法就是解开我设置的所有关卡，我还打算给它们起名字，你知道的，我要把它做成一件煞有介事的事。所以，就是像这样。或者说，有人真的从我家门廊前偷了快递，我当时非常难过，难受了大概一周，然后我想：“等等。要是我设计一种方法来报复这些家伙呢？因为我都能把探测车送到火星上。”所以我应该能想出某种既好玩又刺激的方法来进行一点复仇。所以，有非常非常多的想法完全来自日常对话和日常生活。关键在于，你必须时刻调动大脑的那部分思维，去想：我的解决方案会是什么？如果你能开始像这样去思考，我想你会惊讶地发现，原来随时随地都有那么多机会摆在你的眼前。你只需要把自己的思绪带入那个空间。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
opportunity and I was like, wait, what if I really made them earn it with an eight part ninja warrior obstacle course? The birds could come and go as they please. The only way for a squirrel to do that is if he like solved all my things and I'm going to name them and, you know, I'm going to make it a thing. So, it's like uh or someone literally stole a package from my porch and I was very sad and I was sad for about a week and then I was like, "Wait a second. What if I devised a way to get back at these guys because I put her over on Mars." So, I should be able to come up with something that would be fun and exciting to get some revenge. So, so much so many of the ideas just come from conversations, everyday life. The key is you just always have to have that part of your brain engaged of like what would my solution be? So if you can start thinking like that, I think you'd be surprised how many opportunities are right in front of you at all times. You just got to get your head in that mind space.
</details>

而且我认为这确实……我有时确实会收到家长的这类反馈，比如：我的孩子只看了一个 Mark Rober 的视频，突然间他们就去发明各种方法，比如收集屋顶上的雨水去点亮灯泡，或者拿遥控器改装成某种光束传感器，当他们的姐姐或妹妹走进房间时就能感应到。我非常喜欢这样，你知道的。我喜欢成为催化剂，让每个人都在自己的领域里去思考，怎样才能想出属于自己的绝妙主意。它们不一定非要那么复杂，对吧？但真的，如果你现在正在看这个视频，无论你是个孩子还是个成年人，一个很好的思考切入点就是：当你躺在床上时，怎样才能把房间里的灯关掉？你知道，那可以有许多不同的方式。也许是通过一根穿过来的绳子。也许是一个带配重的东西。也许是一个你用飞镖枪射击就能击中的靶子。用很多绝缘胶带、一点巧思和房子周围的废弃物品就能搞定。对你来说，那会是什么样子的？一旦你做到了，你就会意识到，太酷了。我学会了这个，现在我要去琢磨另一件新事情。我该怎么让我的门能自动关上？你可以……这真的是一种看待世界非常有趣的方式。

好的，有好多人，13 岁的 Paul、11 岁的 Sophul、7 岁的 Luca，他们都想知道，工程中最困难或最有趣的部分是什么。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
And I think that is some I do get that feedback sometimes from parents where it's like my kid watched one Mark Robber video and suddenly they're inventing ways to you know capture the rainwater on the roof and and and power a light bulb and to take the remote and turn it into like a you know a beam sensor when their kid their sister enters the room. I I love that, you know. I love being the catalyst for everyone thinking in their own domain how they can, you know, come up with their own clever ideas. They don't have to be that complicated, right? But like literally, if you're watching this right now and and you're a kid or if you're an adult, like, you know, a good thought starter is like, how do you turn off the light in your room while you're in bed? You know, that could look like a lot of different. Maybe it's a string on a thing that comes through. Maybe it's like a a weighted thing. Maybe it's like a a target that you shoot your dart gun at that hits it. You know that that can be a very using a lot of just duct tape and ingenuity and junk around your house. Like what does that look like for you? And then once you do that, you'll realize like that was cool. I learned this and now I'm gonna figure out this new thing. How do I make my door so it automatically closes? You know, you can just it's it's a really fun way of seeing the world. Well, ton of folks, Paul who is 13, Sophul who's 11, Luca who's seven, they all want to know what is the hardest or most interesting part of engineering.
</details>

>> 嗯，我认为最困难的部分同时也是最有趣的部分，那就是它以前从未被做出来过。你正在把一件从未存在过的东西召唤到现实中。所以，这就是机会所在。而挑战在于，它不存在，可能正是因为要让它存在会极其困难。所以这就是一个持续不断的反馈循环。人们在试图制造某种东西时最容易犯的头号错误，就是希望他们的最终版本……希望他们的第一版就是最终版。世界上存在的任何东西都不是这样的。你知道，就像这里的这把剪刀，经历了非常多的原型迭代才变成最终的形态。一开始绝对不是长成现在这个样子的。这里的这些耳机也是一样，甚至是这顶帽子也是一样。为了达到现在的状态，它所经历的修改次数多达数百次。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> Um, I think the hardest part is also the most fun part, which is like it's it's never been done before. You're willing something into existence that's never existed. So, that's the opportunity. The challenge is like it doesn't exist because it might be really hard to make it exist. And so it's just this constant feedback loop. The number one mistake people make when they're trying to build something is they want their final version to be their to be their to be they're the first version to be their last the final. And nothing that exists in the world. You know these scissors right here went through so many prototypes to get to this final form. Did not start looking like this. And so same with these these headphones, same with this literally this cap. Like the amount of revisions that this has gone through to get here is in the hundreds.
</details>

>> 所以挑战就在于，先从某个地方开始。拿硬纸板和绝缘胶带做出你的第一个原型，然后越来越好，不断改进，直到它变成一个运转非常良好的东西。每一次你解决几个问题，做另一个版本，再解决几个问题。所以，这就是巨大的机会，也是巨大的挑战：这是一项艰苦的工作，是一个不断迭代的过程，但那也正是乐趣所在。这是一段旅程。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> And so that is the challenge is like just start somewhere. Start with cardboard and duct tape as your first prototype and then get better and better and refine it until it is like something that works really well. And each time you solve a few more problems and do another version, solve a few more problems. Um, so, so that's the great opportunity and the great challenge is it's a it's a it's work and it's iterative, but that that's the fun part. It's a journey.
</details>

>> 嗯，Mark，在我们接近谈话尾声之际，你知道，我们聊了这么多关于你在 Class Crunch Labs 所做的事情，以及这些年来你整体在科普内容创作方面所做的工作。当你80岁成为一个老人、回首自己所做的一切时，你觉得你怎样才会知道 CR……不好意思，Class Crunch Labs 奏效了？你怎样才会知道自己所做的是成功的？

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> Um, well, Mark, as we're winding down the conversation, um, you know, we've talked so much about what you're creating with Class Crunch Labs and just what you've been doing just in general with creating science content for all these years. when you're uh you know 80 or an old man and you're looking back at all that you've done, how how do you think you'll know that CR excuse me, Class Crunch Labs worked? How will you know that what you've done was successful?
</details>

>> 呃，我永远不会走到那一步。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> Uh I'll never get to that point
</details>

>> 而且我觉得这样挺好的。比如我喜欢去攀登高山，你懂吗？我不太经常回头看。更多的是在想，噢，我们还能做点别的什么呢？所以，是否成功就留给别人去评判吧。我的意思是我会……我会一直分析它，找出我们还能做些什么微调来让它变得更好。但我不会花很多心思去回头看，然后感慨：“哇，看看我们取得的所有成就。”因为还有太多酷炫的事情可以去做。总有更多的山峰和好玩的事情。这才是乐趣所在，你知道吗？是追求过程中的快乐，而不是对快乐的追求。所以，正如我刚才所说，当我拿来一件东西，通过迭代让它变得更好一点，再让它变得更好一点，这时我能获得最大的乐趣和幸福感。因此，如果等我80岁的时候别人想看着它说：“噢，这做得很棒。”从而觉得算是大功告成了，那挺好。但我自己不会这样。我大概会说：“是的，但我们在韩国还没彻底搞定呢，所以我们去把那做好吧。”这并不是说我不快乐或不满足。我确实感到非常满足，但我获得的满足感来自于那种升级晋级的过程。然后，毫无疑问，我认为到某个阶段你会发现，你身后留下了一整套不言自明且有望产生影响的作品。但是我绝对不希望有任何东西以我的名字命名，比如一栋大楼。我不相信代际财富这一套。我不喜欢……所有那些东西对我来说，甚至“传承”这个概念，我都不觉得有多大意义。我个人就是无法理解它。那不是我工作的目的。所以，我很感激这个问题。我认为这是个很好的问题，借这个机会我也正好说明，这甚至让我感到有点困惑，因为我的大脑根本不是那样运转的。我的想法始终是：我们还能做什么？我们还可以怎样改进它？

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> and and I'm okay with that. Like I love mountains to climb, you know? I I I don't tend to look back very often. It's more just like, oh, but what else could we do? So, it's like someone else can can figure out if it's been successful or not. Like that's I mean I will I will I will always be analyzing it and figure out what more we could do to tweak it to make it better. But like I don't engage a lot in like, oh, let me look back and be like, "Wow, look at all we've accomplished." Because there's so much more cool stuff to do. Like there's always more mountains and and fun things. And like that is the joy, you know? It's the It's the happiness of the pursuit, not the pursuit of happiness. And so I get the most joy and happiness when it's like I take something exactly what I just said, the iteration and like making it a little bit better. Making a little bit better. And so if someone else wants to look at it when I'm 80 and be like, "Oh, it was good." And therefore, you know, mission accomplished, great. But I won't. I'll be like, "Yeah, but we, you know, we haven't got it nailed in Korea yet. So let's do that." And that's not to say like I'm not happy or satisfied. Like I do take great satisfaction, but I take satisfaction in like the the leveling up. And then hey, sure enough, what you find I think at some point is you have this body of work behind you that's speaks for itself that hopefully has impact. But like I will I don't ever want anything named after me like a building. I don't I don't believe in generational wealth. I don't like all that stuff is so like even the concept of legacy to me doesn't even make a ton of sense. I don't personally I just don't get it. That's not what I'm working for. And so um I I I appreciate the question. I think it's the right question to ask and it's an opportunity to just say like it almost is confusing to me because that's just not how my brain works. It's like what else can we do? How else could we improve this?
</details>

>> 是的，关键在于过程。你就是一直身处其中……

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> Yeah, it's the process. you're just constantly in there
</details>

>> 处于这个过程之中。如果你这样做，事情往往会进展得很顺利。如果你每年递增式地提升5%，你知道，那就是复利效应带来的成果。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> of the process and then if you do that they're things I think do tend to work well if you incrementally every year you're improving by 5% that's like compounding results you know.
</details>

>> 是的。

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> Yeah.
</details>

>> 嗯，这些话真可以作为人生座右铭，或许也是一个非常好的收尾之处。非常感谢你，Mark，感谢你分享的一切。我学到了很多。我知道评论区里的每一个人也都在说他们受益匪浅。所以感谢你今天抽出时间与我们分享这一切。

太棒了。非常感谢大家。真的很感谢你们的时间。

[音乐]

>> [音乐]

<details><summary>Original English</summary>
>> Well that those feel like words to live by and and maybe a good place to end. Thank you so much Mark for everything you've shared. I've learned a lot. I know everyone in the in in the comments have been saying how much they've learned. So thank you for sharing all this with us and taking some time today. Love it. Thank you guys so much. Really appreciate the time. [music]

>> [music]
</details>