废墟背后的灵魂食粮:克拉马托尔斯克的两种视角
几年前,我站在乌克兰东部的克拉马托尔斯克街头。当时一栋居民公寓楼刚遭到俄罗斯巡航导弹的袭击。我清晰地记得大楼的正面被整块削掉,你能直接看到暴露在外的起居室和厨房,烧焦的个人物品四处散落,混杂在瓦砾碎石之中。现场的一侧站着武器核查人员,中间停着一台挖掘机,而在这一切的中央,自然少不了各路新闻记者,他们正忙着采访当事人。其中有一位脸上满是黑灰的女士格外令人动容,她从废墟中扒出自己的随身物品,堆在地上,然后整个人坐在上面看守着。这就是每天夜晚在全世界新闻屏幕上循环播放的画面。我当时坐下来画下了这一幕——画作最前方那个身着黑衣的正是她。这种场景极其抓人眼球,不可否认,毁灭本身确实有一种摄人心魄的力量。
然而,当我绕到同一栋大楼的后方时,却看到了截然不同的一幕:整座图书室的书籍被气浪掀飞,散落在一片玫瑰花丛里。在荆棘与玫瑰之间,站着70岁的彼得罗(Petro)。在例行的晨间散步中,他走到这里便再也无法挪步。他觉得停下来是自己的责任,于是将散落的书一本本捡起,码成整整齐齐的小堆。当我画他时,他看着我并说道:“我从小受到的教导就是,如果看到地上有一块面包,我一定要把它捡起来。对待书也是一样,它们是灵魂的食粮。”二十多年来,我画过乌克兰的万人坑、阿富汗的剖宫产手术,也画过叙利亚战争。在这漫长的岁月里,我反复体会到一个真相:战争有着许多副面孔。但在克拉马托尔斯克那个清晨,对比显得如此强烈。真正击中我内心的正是彼得罗——一个伫立在暴行废墟之中的温柔灵魂。
英文原文
A couple of years ago, I stood on the streets in eastern Ukraine, in Kramatorsk, in the aftermath of a Russian cruise missile strike on a residential apartment building. I remember the front of the building was blown off. You could see a living room and a kitchen inside, belongings burnt, scattered on the floor, mixed in with the rubble. There were some weapons inspectors on one side, an excavator in the middle, and of course, in amongst it all, the journalists were there, trying to interview those involved. One lady in particular had soot on her face. It was very moving to watch. She gathered her belongings from the rubble, and she put them on the floor, and she sat on them for safekeeping. These are the sorts of scenes that are broadcast around the world every night. And I sat and drew this image -- that’s her in the black at the front. I found them to be so moving. And let me tell you -- the destruction is truly captivating.
But around the back of the same building, I found a library of books had been blasted into a rose garden, and in amongst the thorns and the roses stood Petro, age 70. On his morning walk, he couldn't go any further. He felt it was his duty to stop, pick up the books, stack them in neat little piles. And as I drew him, he challenged me, and he said "I was brought up that if I see a loaf of bread on the floor, I'll pick it up. It's the same with books. They are food for the soul." I've drawn mass graves in Ukraine, a cesarean in Afghanistan and the war in Syria. And over two decades, I’ve had one realization over and over, that there are many truths to war. But on that morning in Kramatorsk, in Ukraine, it was so stark. It was Petro that captured my heart, this gentle soul standing amidst atrocity.
画笔作为沉思媒介:跨越百年的世纪见证
这就是我的职业。我为报刊杂志进行现场墨水写生。在乌克兰驻留的数周时间里,我的使命变成了“慢下来”,去探寻更深层的东西。我逐渐领悟到:新闻报道(News: 传递即时事实与事件信息的媒介)能告诉我们发生了什么,而写生绘画(Drawing: 借助现场凝视记录感知与情感的艺术形式)却能展现置身其中的真实感受。在基辅,我遇见了99岁的奥尔加女士(Madame Olga)。由于年事已高,空袭警报拉响时她甚至无法从床上爬起来。我记得她枕头底下塞着一本《圣经》。她的神志有时有些模糊,把普京和希特勒混为一谈,但她紧紧攥着翻译的手,两人的脸只相隔大约六英寸。在某一刻极其清醒的瞬间,她开口说:“如果你安静下来,我会从头给你讲我的故事。”
她出生于1923年,早年与父亲一同被送往集体农庄。她挺过了那场夺走400万乌克兰人生命的乌克兰大饥荒(Holodomor: 20世纪30年代苏联时期发生在乌克兰的人为大饥荒)。二战爆发后,她沦为纳粹家庭的奴隶苦工。她向我回忆起那家人曾拿虫子喂她。另一次她拼命逃到了警察局,但警察却把她直接送回了那个纳粹家庭。战争结束后,她徒步走回乌克兰,在路上遇见了她后来的丈夫。他们成家并育有四个孩子,此后她又平静地生活了整整80年。如果不是因为现场写生这一需要长久停留的创作过程,我不可能与奥尔加共享这段珍贵的时刻,今天也无法将她的故事传递给你们。在我们相遇几个月后,她在百岁生日前夕于睡梦中安详离世。
英文原文
This is what I do. I draw for magazines and newspapers, in ink, on location. And over weeks and weeks in Ukraine, it became my mission to be slow, to delve deeper. And I found that the news can tell us what happened, but the drawing can show us how it felt.
In Kyiv, I met Madame Olga, aged 99. She was too old to get out of her bed when the air-raid sirens rang. I remember she had a Bible tucked under her pillow. She was very muddled, she was confusing Putin and Hitler, and she held the translator's hands about six inches from her face. And in this moment of wonderful clarity, she said, "If you be quiet, I will tell you the story from the beginning." She was born in 1923. She was taken to a collective farm with her father. She survived the Holodomor -- the great famine which killed four million Ukrainians. When World War II started, she worked as a slave for a Nazi family. She recounted the story about one time they fed her worms. She ran away, on another occasion, to the police station, but the policeman returned her straight back to the house. When the war ended, she began to walk home to Ukraine. She met her husband on the way -- future husband, I should say. They got married. She had four children. She lived another 80 years. If it hadn't been for the process of drawing, I wouldn’t have shared this moment with Olga, and I wouldn't be able to share it with you. She died a couple of months after we met, peacefully, in her sleep, before her 100th birthday.
撕裂表象后的具体微光:豚鼠战士与病房画约
在我看来,现代新闻报道正在辜负公众的信任:它把毁灭置于人性之上,带来的是两极分化与情感疲劳,同时制造出一种虚幻的确定感,让人陷入无助与绝望之中。面对这种媒体环境,人们选择关掉电视完全无可厚非。而我的解毒剂,就是漫步在街头巷尾,守在街角。我与当地的翻译及当地协调人(Fixer: 为战地记者和外来创作者提供本土联络与支持的专业向导)合作,去探寻那些未被歌颂、低调生活着的普通人。比如23岁的奥列格(Oleg),他是一名综合格斗选手,也是乌克兰的足球迷。战争爆发后,他和足球队的朋友们一起参军抵抗俄军。然而在我为他画画的那天,画面中呈现的却是他的母亲丽莎(Lisa)——当地的一名英语老师——正在给他盛罗宋汤。他端着卡拉什尼科夫步枪摆出姿势,但更罕见的是,他怀里还抱着他的豚鼠“杏仁”(Almond)。在整个作画过程中,他一直亲昵地对着杏仁耳语:“你真是只大肥猪,你真是只大肥猪。”
正是像谢尔盖(Sergei)这样的人提醒着我,即使在我站在舞台上的这一刻,这些故事仍在真实发生。他是所有人中最普通的一位,本是一名建筑师,房子遭到俄罗斯导弹袭击时屋顶塌陷砸伤了他的头部。我在医院里见到了他,当时他的头上缠着厚厚的绷带。我通过护士翻译询问是否能为他画一张画,他微微扬起下巴看着我,咧嘴灿烂地笑了起来,说:“可以,但我也要给你画一张。”于是我们非常正式地约好了第二天碰面。当我次日回到病房时,为了防备可能的爆炸冲击波,窗户上依然贴着封箱胶带。我们就这样坐在病房里互相给对方画肖像。我们没有任何共同的语言,而且两人都对自己的画技感到有些害羞。就像所有真正的艺术家一样,他把画作的问题归咎于手头的画具。如果他知道我现在把这张画展示给在座的各位,心底大概会暗暗感到自豪。谢尔盖,这就是属于你的故事。
英文原文
I believe the news is failing us. It promotes destruction before humanity. It's polarizing and fatiguing. It gives the illusion of certainty. You might feel helpless or hopeless. We'd certainly be forgiven for turning it off. My antidote is to wander the streets and stand on corners. I work with local translators and fixers to interview the unsung and the understated. Like Oleg, 23-year-old mixed martial arts fighter and football fan from Ukraine. He joined the military to fight the Russians with his football friends. But on this day, I drew him being served borscht by his mother, Lisa, the English teacher from that town, and he posed for me with his Kalashnikov, but also, more unusually, with his guinea pig, Almond. And throughout the sitting, he whispered to Almond affectionately, "You are a big pig." "You are a big pig."
It's people like Sergei that remind me that these stories are continuing as I stand in front of you. Perhaps the most ordinary of them all. An architect whose house fell on his head when it was hit by a Russian missile. And I met him in the hospital, bandage wrapped around his head. I asked if I could draw him and the nurse translated. And he looked at me down his nose and he grinned from ear to ear, and said, "Yes, but I will also draw you." And, very formally, a date was arranged for the next day, and I came back and we sat in one of the wardrooms. The windows were still sellotaped up in case there was an explosion. And we sat and we drew each other. We didn't share any common language. We were both shy about our drawings. Like all good artists, he blamed his tools for the quality of his picture. And he'd probably be secretly proud to know that I'm showing you this. Sergei, this is your story.
从快餐消费到真正凝视:以缓慢抵御暴力的见证哲学
当然,这些仅仅是来自乌克兰的四个故事。多年来,在叙利亚、塔吉克斯坦、加沙以及伊拉克,我遇见并画下了数百个这样的人。但在即时新闻铺天盖地的时代,为什么我们还需要去了解一只叫“杏仁”的豚鼠、建筑师谢尔盖、高祖母奥尔加,或者哈姆多(Hamdo)、丽莎和迪米特里(Dimitri)?答案或许不言自明:因为他们完全有可能就是我们当中的任何一个人。他们才是战争最真实的代价。我今晚向你们讲述他们、分享他们的故事,是因为他们都是极其平凡的普通人——恐惧与暴行骤然倾泻进他们的生活,而他们选择用自己的内心去默默抵抗。
在结束演讲之际,我想做一次坦白。或者说是一种承认,尽管对艺术家而言承认这一点往往很难:事实证明,这一切的核心从来不是绘画本身,绘画只是一种让自己能坐得更久一点、去给予时间的借口。我们今天听到了许多关于精准倾听的讨论,而这关乎于观察与正确地看见。写生是我所知道的唯一能达成这种看见的方式。在今天,我邀请大家——甚至如果可以的话,我恳请大家——去见证这些故事,而不是简单地消费它们;学着主动慢下来,去珍视人与人之间真实的连接。
英文原文
Of course, these are only four stories from Ukraine. But over the years, in Syria and Tajikistan, Gaza and Iraq, I have met and drawn hundreds of other people. But why, in the age of immediate news, do you need to know about Almond, the guinea pig, or Sergei the architect or Olga, the great-great-grandmother? Or Hamdo, Lisa, Dimitri? Well perhaps it’s obvious: I believe they could so easily have been one of us. They are the true consequences of war. And I tell you about them, I share them with you tonight because they are ordinary people who had terror poured on their lives and resisted it with their hearts.
I would like to finish with a confession. More of an admission, if you like, but a difficult one for artists, I think, to admit. As it turns out, it isn't really about the painting at all. That's just an excuse to sit a little longer, to give time. We've heard about listening accurately today. This is about observing, seeing properly. Drawing is the only way I know how to do that. But today, I invite you -- more than that actually, if I'm allowed -- I urge you to witness these stories and not consume them. To be deliberately slow and to cherish human connection. Thank you for listening.