宁德时代CEO曾毓群:电池巨头的市场策略、研发创新与全球布局 Norges Bank Investment Management 2024-09-18

引言:宁德时代的全球领先地位

Nicola Tangan: 大家好,欢迎来到“In Good Company”。我是挪威主权财富基金(Norges Bank Investment Management: 挪威政府运营的全球最大主权财富基金)的首席执行官Nicola Tangan。今天,我们有幸邀请到一位杰出的嘉宾——全球最大的电池生产商宁德时代(CATL: Contemporary Amperex Technology Co. Limited,中国新能源科技公司)的创始人兼首席执行官曾毓群(Robin Zeng)。宁德时代不仅是全球最大的电池生产商,它还占据了这个庞大市场高达40%的份额,这真是令人惊叹。

View/Hide Original English

hi everybody and welcome to in Good Company I'm Nicola tangan and the CEO of the Norwegian wealth fund and today we have an incredible guest Robin Zang the founder and CEO of catl the world largest battery producer now it's not only the world largest it's got a whopping 40% of this Mega Market wow

Nicola Tangan: 那么,曾总,这一切是如何发生的?你们是如何在这个巨大的市场中占据40%份额的呢?

View/Hide Original English

so Robin how did this come about how is it possible to end up with 40% of such a big Market

曾毓群: 不不,还没到40%。准确地说,是37.5%,不到40%。但我认为最重要的是,宁德时代的产品确实满足了市场对电动出行(e-mobility: 电动汽车和交通工具)的巨大需求。要提供正确的产品,就需要正确的技术。在我们的领域,这更像是原材料和化学材料的创新,它们能真正带来好的产品。

View/Hide Original English

no no not not yet 40% okay to be correct it's 37.5% something that less than 40 but I think the most important is L products definitely the market need a lot of right products to do the uh immobility so right product you need the right uh technology so in our world is more like a ra chemical ra material which really have a good product

曾毓群: 这一系列产品最终是为了满足消费者的目的,这就是为什么消费者真正喜欢它们,也因此客户(customers)愿意将这些产品安装到他们的汽车中。这就是我们能够为数百万辆汽车提供动力的原因。

View/Hide Original English

so this group product is a finished to the purpose of the consumer that's why consumer really love that that's why the customers alls would like to make these products and put this product into their car that's why we can power the millions of cars

Nicola Tangan: 曾总,尽管你们的市场地位令人难以置信,但可能有些听众还不了解你们的产品。您能否简单介绍一下你们有哪些类型的产品?

View/Hide Original English

so um despite your uh incredible Market position there may be some listeners who don't uh know what your products are so just uh very briefly what type of products do you have

核心产品与发展历程

曾毓群: 我们主要有两大类产品。第一类是用于电动出行(e-mobility)的电池,我们称之为动力电池。你可以在特斯拉(Tesla: 美国电动汽车及能源公司)的Model 3Model Y等车型中看到我们的产品,以及所有中国汽车制造商和许多原始设备制造商(OEM: Original Equipment Manufacturer,指代工生产或生产自有品牌产品的厂商)的汽车中。这种电池我们称之为为整车提供动力的电池。

View/Hide Original English

we have h two major product one is the battery we call a battery for the immobility so you can have the product in the Tesla's car model 3 Model Y so in all the Chinese car makers or also in many of omm's cars so this battery we call to power the whole car so is a b b

曾毓群: 另一类产品是用于储能的电池。你知道,所有可再生能源,比如风力涡轮机和太阳能电池,都需要储能电池来储存和调节不稳定的可再生能源供应,使这些能源供应变得非常稳定、可预测,并且非常适合工业及其他用途。

View/Hide Original English

another product is we make a battery for the energy storage you know all the renewable energy like a wind turbine and the solar cell that's why you need a a storage battery who can storage regulate the uh unstabled renewable energy supplies which make this energy Supply become very stable very predictable and very Fitness to the industry use and other use

Nicola Tangan: 从零开始发展到全球市场份额37.5%,主要步骤是什么?这花了你们多长时间?

View/Hide Original English

what's been the main steps uh from uh going from kind of zero to uh 37.5% world market share how long has it taken you

曾毓群: 是的,我们花了大约12年时间,从零达到了37.5%的市场份额。但这不仅仅是这12年的功劳,因为我们的团队在这个行业已经耕耘了四分之一个世纪,也就是25年。我们从25年前就开始从事锂离子电池(Li-ion battery: 一种可充电电池,主要依靠锂离子在正负极之间移动来工作)业务,当时主要是用于手机、笔记本电脑和所有消费电子产品。所以,我们从25年前就拥有了类似的技术基础。

View/Hide Original English

yeah we take almost uh 12 years to from zero to the to this uh 37.5% the major is not because of this this only this 12 years because our team have been working on this industry for now it's a quarter Century 25 years ago we start business with this L ion battery which is definitely is for the mobile phone for the Notebook for the all the consumer electronic applications so we have the similar technology from from 25 years ago

研发投入与竞争策略

Nicola Tangan: 您认为今天谁是你们的竞争对手?

View/Hide Original English

who do you consider your competitors uh today

曾毓群: 我认为,今天的竞争对手是我们自己。因为我们还有很多事情要做,尤其是在电化学方面。你知道,今天的材料,我们仍然使用正极材料(cathode material),比如磷酸铁锂(lithium iron phosphate, LFP: 一种锂离子电池正极材料,成本较低,安全性高)和镍钴锰酸锂(NCM: 镍钴锰三元锂电池,能量密度较高)。材料仍在发展,例如硅基负极(silicon)。最重要的是,我们必须发明新的化学体系。

View/Hide Original English

I think uh the competitor is ourself because we don't have uh we still have a lot of to do especially on the uh electrical chemical side you know the material today we still in Castle material uh like lium ion phosphate and the NCM and the material still on the quy some silicon most important is the new chemistries we have to invent

曾毓群: 只有发明新的化学体系,才能适应更多的用途和消费者的更多需求,例如低温性能。

View/Hide Original English

so only invent the new chemistries can also fit more usage more requirement from consumer for example low temperature performance

Nicola Tangan: 您说您的竞争对手是您自己,您不担心其他竞争对手吗?

View/Hide Original English

you say that uh your competitor is yourself are you not worried about any other competitors

曾毓群: 我不把他们视为竞争对手。实际上,我们乐于看到更多的人加入这个旅程,真正进行发明创造,而不是简单地模仿。这些发明能够通过真正优秀的产品性能和技术,帮助消费者和客户感到满意。因为只有在发明和创造力方面的竞争,才能帮助这个行业在未来健康发展。

View/Hide Original English

I don't consider them as a competitors actually we love to have more people join in this journey which you really can have the inventions it's not a copycat it's a inventions which is can help to make the consumer make the customer happy with their real good performance of the products and Technologies because only the competitions in the invention competitions in the creativity which can help this industry very healthy to grow in the Futures

Nicola Tangan: 那么,国家支持在达到这种市场地位方面有多重要?

View/Hide Original English

and how important is uh uh State support in getting uh to that type of position

曾毓群: 在中国,情况更为复杂。因为中国人努力制造许多适合消费者使用的产品。所以,中国的原始设备制造商(OEM)更倾向于倾听消费者的需求,然后比世界上任何人都更快地做出好的设计。这就是为什么他们能够推出大量优秀产品的原因。

View/Hide Original English

but in China is uh more more complicated because uh Chinese try to make a lot of products which fit to the consumer usage so uh Chinese o more like a we we we call it hearing more the request from the consumer then they make it a good design faster than anyone else in the in the world that's why they can roll out a lot of good products

曾毓群: 为了支持中国的原始设备制造商(OEM)在这方面的发展,宁德时代也得到了很好的训练,学会了如何快速掌握需求,如何快速调整生产,以支持他们,提供高性价比和高质量的产品给我们的客户。这就是整个故事的不同之处。

View/Hide Original English

so in order to support the trines OEM on this aspect seat have been you know being well trained to how to quick faster grass and how to quick faster to remark the production to support that the cost performance effectively and the quality high quality products to our customer let's the whole story make a difference

Nicola Tangan: 这很复杂,所以您拥有博士学位是件好事。但是,你们在研发方面有多少人?

View/Hide Original English

you know it's complicated that's why it's good that you have a PhD but um um how many people have you got in uh in research and development

曾毓群: 是的,我们有超过2万名工程师,都是我们领域非常优秀的人才。因为他们需要关注很多方面。

View/Hide Original English

yeah we have more than 20,000 uh people engineer very good talents in my uh area because uh uh they need a focus on many aspects

Nicola Tangan: 2万名工程师,这几乎和我家乡的人口一样多。他们都做些什么呢?

View/Hide Original English

but I mean 20 20,000 is nearly as many people that live in my hometown so what do they do

曾毓群: 这2万多人中,有些人专注于基础材料结构,有些人专注于阳离子(cations),有些人专注于材料的集成,还有些人专注于未来的化学。例如,我们称之为“科学人工智能”(AI for Science: 利用人工智能技术加速科学发现和材料研发),需要利用人工智能(Artificial Intelligence, AI: 模拟人类智能的计算机系统)来尝试找出超越锂离子电池的下一代革命性材料和化学系统。我们还需要在电池管理系统和软件方面进行一些研究指导。

View/Hide Original English

uh least 20,000 people is uh some people is focus on the basic material structures some people is focus on cations some people is focus on the interation of the materials some people is focus on the future chemistry for example we call AI for Science and need to use artificial intellig to try to find out the next revolutionary material and the chemical system beyond the LM ions we need to have some research guide on the you know on the battery Management systems and softwares all together

曾毓群: 总共有大约21,000名工程师,他们中有数百名博士,还有许多硕士。这些年轻人平均在这里工作了三年或五年以上,他们已经变得非常优秀。我希望他们未来能有更多的创新,帮助人类应对气候变化,专注于可再生能源。

View/Hide Original English

like 20 21,000 uh Engineers they have uh sever hundred phds you know many many Masters so loan kids have been working here for average more than three or five years they they have become very good T and I hope uh they can have more Innovations in the future to help the the human uh climate changing focus on these uh uh renewable energies

中国电池产业的优势与全球竞争

Nicola Tangan: 你们拥有的人才库令人难以置信。我看到两篇被广泛引用的电池技术论文中,有三分之二来自中国,而美国只有12%。此外,中国有50多个电池相关的研究生项目,而美国只有少数几个。那么,世界其他国家如何才能与你们竞争呢?

View/Hide Original English

the talent pool you have uh is incredible right I saw that two out of three widely cited papers on Battery Technology came out of China uh only 12% coming out of the US also you in China have more than 50 graduate programs in batteries compared to only a few uh in the US so um how how can the rest of the world possibly compete with you

曾毓群: 大约12年前,当安格拉·默克尔(Angela Merkel: 德国前总理)访问中国时,我们进行了一些讨论。那时,德国人已经在思考为什么他们不能制造出好的电池,因为他们能制造出非常好的发动机和变速箱。所以,德国人认为他们也能制造出非常好的电池。

View/Hide Original English

almost 12 years ago uh when the Angela M visit China we have some discussions among that in that time the German people already thinking about how why they cannot make a good batteries because they make a very good engines they make a very good gear boss so uh you know German people think they can make a very good batteries

曾毓群: 所以,当我们讨论这个问题时,我告诉他们,幸运的是,或者说不幸的是,中国有很多大学仍在研究电化学。通常,电化学被认为是低端领域,因为如果你从电化学专业毕业,你很难找到一份好工作。你只能找到与电池或防腐蚀(antic cions)相关的工作。这些都是低薪工作,所以这些理论已经很老旧了。

View/Hide Original English

that's why when we have some discussions on that I told them fortunately unfortunately is uh China have a lot of uh universi still working on the electrical chemical so usually electrical chemistry is uh is very low end people looking at because if you graduate from electrical chemistry you cannot find a good job you know you can only find uh people for the L abilities you only find a job for the antic cions so all this kind of uh low pay job that's why uh they being very old uh uh Theory

曾毓群: 但我知道,美国有很多好大学和学生,他们不想专注于这个领域,他们想专注于金融、半导体等能获得更高薪水的工作。但中国有很多学生必须上大学,所以他们发现更多人会去研究电化学。这就是为什么我们拥有大量人才,相比美国和德国。

View/Hide Original English

but uh I know United States a lot of good universities and the students they don't want to focus on this they want to focus on finance focus on the uh semiconductors yeah they need to get a higher pay from the leas but the China there's a lot of you know students who uh have to go into University that's why they found more M study on the electrical chemistries that's why we have a lot of talents compared to us compared to Germany

曾毓群: 所以,如果美国和德国想要在电池领域迎头赶上或超越,他们可能必须从教育开始。

View/Hide Original English

so if us Germany want to catch up or want to overtake in the bar side probably they have to startop from the uh education

Nicola Tangan: 您对挪威的人才储备有什么看法?

View/Hide Original English

have you got a view on the amount of talent we have in Norway

曾毓群: 我认为您家乡的2万人都很有才华。所以我们需要找出什么样的才能适合什么样的用途,可能不一定是电化学。

View/Hide Original English

I think all 20,000 people in your hometown is all talents so we need to find out what kind of talents to F what kind of use may not be electrical chemistry

电池发明的挑战与规模化生产

Nicola Tangan: 最困难的事情是什么?是发明电池,还是扩大电池生产规模?是制造一个更难,还是制造一千个更难?

View/Hide Original English

what's the most difficult thing is it to uh uh to invent a battery or is it the scaling of battery production you know is it more difficult to make one or to make a thousand

曾毓群: 最困难的事情是理解现实世界中的电化学系统。其他方面,就像我之前提到的,你需要持续20到25年。如何预测并准确进行阳离子测试以表明它已经达到了那种水平,这是可靠性方面的另一个难点。

View/Hide Original English

so most difficult things is understanding of electrical chemical system in the real world and uh other things is follow is like a as I mentioned you have to last 20 25 years let's TR how you predict that and uh accurately A cation test to indicate is already can reach that kind of level uh is another difficulty in reliabilities

曾毓群: 还有规模化生产和低成本。每个人都在寻找非常低成本的电池,因为他们总是将电池与汽油发动机(internal combustion engine: 燃烧燃料产生动力的发动机)进行比较,而汽油发动机已经发展了100多年,经过了无数次优化。这就是为什么他们给电池施加了太多的负担。

View/Hide Original English

so and the scale up uh Productions and you know low cost everyone looking for very low cost battery because they always compare the battery with the Gathering engine internal combustion engine which have developed more than 100 years optimize and optimized that's why they push too much burden on the batteries

Nicola Tangan: 看起来在欧洲,扩大生产规模确实是个问题。这里有什么特别困难的共同点吗?

View/Hide Original English

it just seems like um uh in Europe there is such a problem scaling up production is there one common thing that's particularly difficult here

曾毓群: 我和许多欧洲电池制造商的首席执行官谈过,他们无法制造出好的产品,是因为他们有错误的设计。其次,他们有错误的工艺。第三,他们有错误的设备。

View/Hide Original English

I talk to the many people European battery maker CEO W canot make a a good product it's because they have a wrong design and secondly they have a wrong process thirdly they have a wrong equipments

曾毓群: 如果他们想要大规模生产,他们就会遇到良品率(utilization problem)问题,之后会有可靠性问题,两三年后还会出现安全问题。所以几乎所有的错误都集中在一起。我不知道这听起来不太好。

View/Hide Original English

how can they scale up if they want to scale up a l they would be have a you problem you utilization problem and later on there will be a Rel reliability problem and two year or 3 years later there will be a safety problem so almost all mistake together so I don't know how that doesn't sound so good

Nicola Tangan: 如果我们从第一个问题开始,您说他们设计错误,这是什么意思?

View/Hide Original English

but if we start with the first one when you said they got the wrong design what do you mean

曾毓群: 是的,从错误的设计开始,这意味着如果他们不理解电化学或侧向反应,正如我提到的,设计就会是错误的。他们从不考虑未来的风险。这就是为什么一天的性能测试看起来很好,但当你想要扩大规模时,当你想要投入生产时,生产过程却无法涵盖你未来所需的一切。

View/Hide Original English

yes stuff from the wrong design it means they if they don't understand the electrical chemistry or side reation as I mentioned the design will be wrong they never cover the risk of the future risk that's why the performance testing in one day looks good then you want to scale up then you want to put the process the process never cover what you need in the future

Nicola Tangan: 那么,考虑到您所说的,欧洲电池生产的应用前景如何?您认为欧洲在十年后会处于什么位置?

View/Hide Original English

what are the applications for European battery production then given what you saying where do you think Europe is going to be in 10 years time for the battery application side

曾毓群: 我们刚刚谈到了电动出行(e-mobility),还有船只和物联网(IoT)。甚至在挪威,卡车和汽车的电动化肯定会非常先进。挪威在可再生能源方面是一个非常先进的国家,也许我们可以合作,制定一个计划,让整个挪威成为一个零碳社会(zero carbon society: 指一个社会或经济体通过减少温室气体排放,实现碳中和甚至碳负排放)。

View/Hide Original English

we we we we just tell about at Le immobility and the boat also and ioto also uh even a bullly TR and the and the kai is definitely since in Norway is definitely a very Advanced uh Nations for this renewable energy maybe we can work together to make a planning to make a Norway the whole Norway become a zero carbon you know Society

曾毓群: 我有信心如何规划电力零碳化。你们有近90%的水力发电(Hydro power: 利用水流的动能发电),对吧?然后你们可以再增加10%的电力,可能来自海上风力发电。

View/Hide Original English

so I have a confidence how to mapping up electricity zeroc carbon is important you have almost 90% Hydro power right then you add up another 10% maybe from the winter by from the from the sea

曾毓群: 另一方面是电动出行。你们的乘用车普及率已经达到90%-95%的新车。我们也可以帮助你们通过我们的换电系统使这些卡车实现零碳化,还可以实现公共交通(PT)的电气化,甚至通过我们称之为RER标准(RER standard: 可能是指某种循环经济或回收利用标准,具体含义需结合上下文)来帮助船舶。

View/Hide Original English

and uh and another size is uh immobilities your passenger car penetration you know already 90 95% of the new cars then we can also can help you to make these trucks to be zero carbon by our swapping battery system and also we can make it a PT electrifications and also can help also even the westel uh with the we call the rer standard

曾毓群: 所以我们可以一起规划,让整个挪威成为世界上第一个实现零碳技术和可再生能源的国家。我认为这需要大约10年时间,到2025年我们将共同实现。而且你们会很高兴从所有这些不同的方面获得大量收入。

View/Hide Original English

so we can planning together to make a whole Norway as a number one in the world to be the zero carbon technology renewable energy nations in the world I think it take around 10 years in 2025 what togethera will be make it and also you would be very happy to have a lot of income from all this kind of different uh you know different things

Nicola Tangan: 嗯,听起来很有趣,但不幸的是,这超出了我的职权范围,不是我能决定的。我只负责投资。当然,我们很高兴能对你们进行了大量投资。

View/Hide Original English

well uh sounds very interesting unfortunately it's above my pay grade it's not my decision I only invest money you know and uh of course we happy that we have invested a lot of money with you

能源存储市场的复杂性与质量标准

Nicola Tangan: 你们从事电池行业已经很长时间了,您觉得创新是在加速还是减速?

View/Hide Original English

now you've been doing batteries for a long time do you feel that uh Innovation is accelerating or decelerating

曾毓群: 我认为创新并没有真正加速太多。你知道,当行业规模较小的时候,当我们从手机电池开始时,技术就像一条直线一样增长,而不是加速。但是当投入更多的资金和更多的人力时,现在每个人都在寻求创新。

View/Hide Original English

I don't see too much is actually acceleration you know when the industry is small when we start from the uh uh uh mobile phone the technology like a growing like a a line not as relations but when to put more money more people inside now everyone looking for the Innovations

曾毓群: 所以,创新是巨大的加速。我们相信会有新的行业和新的化学体系出现。这就是为什么当我们推出产品,当我们投资生产线时,我们必须让生产线更快地折旧。折旧期必须是五年,否则我们就无法适应。

View/Hide Original English

so Innovations big is access relate and uh we believe there will be another new industry a new chemistry come out that's why uh when we put our product when we invest our production line we have to put the production Li have to depreciate faster the depreciation have to be 5 years otherwise uh we want it so new things come out

Nicola Tangan: 很多公司都在推动固态电池(solid-state batteries: 使用固体电解质而非液体电解质的电池,被认为是下一代电池技术),它被认为是颠覆性的。这里的障碍是什么?

View/Hide Original English

so a lot of companies push kind of solid state batteries it's a game changer what are the showstoppers here

曾毓群: 我已经和很多人多次谈论过这个问题。基本的障碍仍然是界面问题——固体与固体之间的界面。无论是正极材料与固体电解质,还是负极材料与固体粉末,固体与固体之间的界面问题,扩散速度比液体电解质慢了大约两个数量级。

View/Hide Original English

well I have been taught this for uh many many times of the different people uh the basic show stop is a steel lay steel is the interface solid and solid interface whenever Castle material with the electrolyte so solid electrolyte solid powder so in anal material or solid powder solid solid interface definitely the problem of the diffusions the speak of the diffusion is almost uh two orders less than a liquid electroly

曾毓群: 这就是为什么人们必须施加很大的压力,将两种固体粉末紧密地压在一起才能使其工作。但在实际应用中,你如何获得如此大的压力呢?所以这是一个根本性的科学技术问题。但我们必须通过不同的新材料发明和新工艺发明来克服它。这需要时间。

View/Hide Original English

that's why people have to put the pressure to put the two solid powder together very heavy pressures then make it works but in the real application days how can you get the the heavy pressures so that's why it is a fundamental uh Science and Technology issues but we have to overcome by different things different uh different new invention of the materials and new invention of the process so it take time

曾毓群: 就技术成熟度等级(Technology Readiness Level, TRL: 衡量技术成熟度的指标)而言,我将其定为第四级。

View/Hide Original English

so in terms of Technology Readiness level I put it at a four level four

Nicola Tangan: 你们还在研究钠离子电池(sodium ion: 一种使用钠离子作为电荷载体的电池,成本低于锂离子电池)和凝聚态电池(condensed metal batteries: 新型电池技术,通常指能量密度更高的半固态或固态电池)。您如何看待这些技术?

View/Hide Original English

you also in sodium ion and condensed metal batteries how do you view these Technologies

曾毓群: 钠离子电池现在已经相当成熟了。我们已经有小规模生产,并供应给一些汽车制造商。唯一的问题是,与今天的磷酸铁锂(LFP)相比,它的能量密度略低。这就是为什么当磷酸铁锂更便宜时,人们倾向于选择它而不是钠离子电池

View/Hide Original English

the sodium ion is quite mature now we already have the production uh small production to the some of the car makers the only problem is the quite a little bit low lower energy density compared with ion phosphate today that's why when ion phosphate is cheaper people tend to select ion phosphate rather than sodium ion

曾毓群: 但我们正在开发第二代钠离子电池,它与第一代相比会非常出色。所以我们相信它将在小型车和短续航里程汽车的初始阶段取代20%到30%的磷酸铁锂电池。

View/Hide Original English

but we have developing the second generation of sodium ion which can be a very good compared with the first generation so we believe it will be a 20 to 30% replacement of lion phosphate in a smaller car on the shorter range of the cars at the initial stage

曾毓群: 至于凝聚态电池,我为此感到自豪,因为它在电动出行应用中表现非常好,尽管今天它非常昂贵。我们正在努力,争取让它的成本降低到今天的两倍或1.5倍。这样我们就可以将这种电池用于需要高能量密度的高端汽车,以实现更高的速度和更长的续航里程。

View/Hide Original English

as of the that's matter battery is uh I'm proud of that because uh if it is very good in imoto application is a very expensive today and uh we are working hard on that try to make it uh you know maybe uh two times compared today or 1.5 times so we can use this battery to the very highend car which should need energy density uh for the speed on the higher range

Nicola Tangan: 当您审视您的生产流程等,您的成功供应链的关键是什么?例如,你们拥有自己的锂矿,对吗?在供应链方面,你们的优势是什么?

View/Hide Original English

when you look at your process and so on what's the key to your your successful supply chain I mean you for instance own your own lithium mine right what are your uh advantages in when you look at your supply chain

曾毓群: 通常,人们必须根据应用来审视供应链。例如,几年前人们说,哇,镍钴非常重要,因为电池将用于大型应用,所以你需要投资镍,特别是钴矿。

View/Hide Original English

usually uh people have to look at a Supply Chain by the applications for example uh several years ago people say wow Niel cobal is very important because the battery will going into big applications that's why you need to have a invest in nickel you especially in the cobal mining

曾毓群: 但他们不明白的是,我们可以通过结构变化创新来减少钴的应用。所以钴的用量从33%减少到3%,甚至现在我们可以完全去除钴,然后我们使用磷酸铁锂,这样钴和镍都变成了零。

View/Hide Original English

but they don't understand is we can have uh making the structure change inovations to reduce the cobal applications so cobal from 33% reduced to 3% and also even now we can remove the cobal then we use the ion phosphate then the cobal become zero nickel become zero

曾毓群: 只有那些理解未来应用发展趋势的技术人员,才知道如何选择好的矿业投资。这可能是我们的优势。所以我们必须非常仔细地理解不同材料的优势,特别是哪种化学系统会成为赢家,然后我们才能做出判断。

View/Hide Original English

so the only the technology people who understand the trend of the developing applications in the future who to know who to choose what kind of uh mining is a good mining Investments that probably is our advantage so we have to very carefully understand the advantage of the different material and especially where chemistry system who will be the winner then we can judge

Nicola Tangan: 那么,当你们在欧洲建立工厂时,如何从中受益?

View/Hide Original English

and how do you benefit from this when you set of factories in Europe

曾毓群: 我在欧洲有两个工厂,一个在德国,一个在匈牙利。我们正在逐步建立供应链。目前,大部分仍然来自中国。

View/Hide Original English

I have two Factory in Europe one is in Germany now one is in uh uh Hungary now the supply chain we establish the uh supply chain gradually now still majority from China

曾毓群: 这就是为什么,例如在挪威,我们肯定可以合作,因为你们有非常低成本的水力发电。所以我们可以一起生产石墨。你知道,石墨是其中最重要的材料之一,它的生产非常耗能。

View/Hide Original English

That's why for example in Norway we definitely we can work together for because you have a very low cost of the hydro Powers so we can make graph graphite together so you know graphite is a one of the most important is the energy consumption changing t a bit

能源存储市场的复杂性与质量标准

Nicola Tangan: 稍微换个话题,关于储能,您如何看待这个市场的发展?

View/Hide Original English

uh energy storage how do you see that market developing

曾毓群: 在我看来,储能市场与交通运输市场规模相似,或者大约是其一半。但储能比交通运输更困难。你知道,它们需要持续20到25年。但很多人认为这更容易,因为他们说这是固定式的,不会移动。

View/Hide Original English

uh energy storage uh in my mind is uh is a similar or maybe half maybe half size of Transportation but energ storage is more difficult than Transportation you know because they lasting they need lasting 20 25 years but many people think this is easier because they say this is a stationary p no don't move uh yes or no

曾毓群: 第二点是,储能通常是一个巨大的电池包。例如,一个1吉瓦时(GWh: Gigawatt-hour,电量单位,等于10亿瓦时)的电池包整个系统至少包含150万个电芯。如果你想想150万个电芯,加上所有的电子元件、机械部件、热管理系统,全部整合到一个系统中,再加上软件,整个1吉瓦时储能系统可能包含700万到900万个组件。这与波音787(Boeing 787: 波音公司生产的宽体客机)的组件数量相似。

View/Hide Original English

number two is the en story usually is a huge pack for example One gwatt battery pack whole system it contains at least 1.5 million cells if think about 1.5 million cells plus all the electronics Mechanicals somal managements put into the system and plus in this software the whole 1 GW hour batteries energy storage system contains maybe 7 to maybe 9 million of the components similar as the Bing 787

曾毓群: 当你以百万分之一(PPM: Parts Per Million,百万分之几,常用于衡量质量缺陷率)的水平控制质量时,这意味着你每天都会遇到产品或组件问题。你必须维护它们,修复它们。未来会有大量的维护成本。而且,退化(degradation)是不同的,一致性(consistency)非常非常难以控制。

View/Hide Original English

so when you control your quality in the one out of the pp PPM that means every day you have the product you have the components a problem you have to maintain that you have to repair that you have a lot of maintenance cost in the future and also degradation is differ consistency is very very difficult to control

曾毓群: 这就是为什么对于宁德时代来说,我们希望将电池制造质量提升到十亿分之一(PPB: Parts Per Billion,十亿分之几)的水平。质量水平提高三个数量级,以适应这种储能用途。所以这很困难。

View/Hide Original English

that's why for C we want to put the battery manufacturing quality up to PPP level one parts per billion so three orders increase the quality level to fit for the usage of this energy storage so it's difficult

曾毓群: 是的,如果每个人都告诉你这很好,你知道,十年后他们会付出代价,也许五年后他们会付出很多钱。

View/Hide Original English

yeah every if you everyone tell you it's good you know 10 years later they to pay maybe 5 years later they have to pay a lot of money

企业文化、个人哲学与社会贡献

Nicola Tangan: 您在宁德时代的企业文化上花了多少时间?您认为与其他公司相比,宁德时代的文化有什么特点?

View/Hide Original English

how much time do you spend on the corpor culture at catl what do you think defines the the culture compared to other companies

曾毓群: 我们的文化是,我们有一个愿景,我们努力成为世界上一个非常创新的技术公司,特别专注于可再生能源,并努力为人类社会在可再生能源方面做出卓越贡献。

View/Hide Original English

uh our culture is uh uh we have a wish we try to be a very innov Innovative uh technology company in the world especially focus on the renewable energy and try to do the excellent contribution to the Human Society in renewable energy IES

曾毓群: 另一方面,我们努力创建一个平台,帮助个人争取精神和物质上的幸福。实际上就是金钱。所以我们需要给他们更多的股票期权,并帮助他们真正为成长而奋斗,特别是创新和自信,成为一个更好的人。

View/Hide Original English

on the other hand we try to create a platform which help the individuals to fight to grow their spirit and material well-being actually is money so we need to give them the more St options and also help them to really fighting for the grow uh especially Innovations and also the confidence bys become a better man

曾毓群: 专注于可再生能源,所以人们相信这段旅程非常有意义,尤其是在宁德时代工作。现在,世界上有1500万辆汽车由宁德时代的电池提供动力。想想看,你们已经帮助减少了大量的碳排放。

View/Hide Original English

the focus on the renewable energy so people people believe very meaningful in this journey especially working in SEO now it's one uh 15 million cars uh 15 million cars in the world powered by Seattle beries so think about that you already help to reduce a lot of carbon

曾毓群: 另一方面,我们不断进行创新,以帮助应对气候变化,并为人类发展实现可持续性。我们努力获得相同的愿景。而且,我们还运用中国文化,我们称之为“修身”。每个人都必须“修身”(refine themsel),然后“利他”(enable others),然后“创新”(drive Innovation)。

View/Hide Original English

on the other hand we are keep on doing these uh Innovations to help the climate change and also sustainability for the for the humans development uh we try to gain the same vision and uh also uh we are using also Chinese uh uh culture we call the refine so everyone have to Define themsel and enable others then uh Drive Innovation so we

曾毓群: 我们总是成功地引入中国传统的“修身、利他、创新”思想。

View/Hide Original English

always we always uh how to say successfully uh in introduce Chinese traditional thinking of refine enable and uh strive innovation

Nicola Tangan: 曾总,您自己是如何努力“修身”的呢?

View/Hide Original English

and Robin how are you still trying to refine the way you work for me

曾毓群: 对我来说,有两种方式。第一是我的哲学,我不想成为最富有的人,或者其他什么,那没有意义。我想把这种财富分享给更多的人,努力创造一个美好的社会,特别是为了可持续发展。这是我对我财富观点的第一点“修身”。

View/Hide Original English

there's two way one is my My Philosophy I don't want to be the I don't want to be the rich guy in the richest guy or whatever it doesn't meaning so I want to uh share that this uh rich or wealthy to many peoples to try to create the good so Society especially for the sustainability this is a number one refine for my my view on my uh uh uh wealthy

曾毓群: 第二是,我需要“修身”,让自己的身体更强壮。否则总是很累,你知道,你无法坚持下去。耐心非常重要,否则无法持久。

View/Hide Original English

second is uh I need to refine myself to be more stronger body you know otherwise it's always tired know you cannot fight the patient is very important otherwise cannot lasting for longer

曾毓群: 第三件事是,我现在正在非常努力地寻找接班人。这三件事现在是我心中的首要任务。

View/Hide Original English

the certain things I'm now trying very hard to find the successors so this is three three things is in my mind now is my more top priorities

Nicola Tangan: 曾总,我相信您和我有一个共同点:我们俩都在白天小睡一会儿,在办公室里打个盹。

View/Hide Original English

so uh Robin I believe you and I we share one thing in common we both uh sleep a bit in the middle of the day we take a a little nap in the office

曾毓群: 是的,这是午休时间。通常我们会在办公室睡30分钟。

View/Hide Original English

yes this is a No Time usually we sleep maybe 30 minutes in office yes

Nicola Tangan: 您白天什么时候睡觉?

View/Hide Original English

when during the day do you sleep

曾毓群: 下午一点左右开始睡,大概30分钟就足够恢复了。

View/Hide Original English

1:00 p.m. uh something like that start sleeping and maybe 30 minutes it's good enough to recover

Nicola Tangan: 这对您有什么帮助?

View/Hide Original English

and what does that do to you

曾毓群: 你会变得更有活力。也许身体在生理上需要它。

View/Hide Original English

you become a more you know energetic maybe the body is physically needed

Nicola Tangan: 您晚上工作到几点?

View/Hide Original English

how long do you work in the evening

曾毓群: 我工作到晚上12点到12点半左右。因为通常一整天的工作,睡觉并不是真的,你需要倾听来自海外的一些信息和消息,尤其是在运营一家国际公司时。你会有24小时跨越云端的信息,但你必须挑选出正确的事情。是的,我很高兴能这样做,基本上没有什么大问题,但我需要锻炼身体。我女儿告诉我的。

View/Hide Original English

I work until 12 12:00 around that 12 12:30 because usually the whole days working sleeping is not really you have to you know uh listen the the the the the the some the information message from overse especially you're running International companies you you you have uh information across the you know the 24 hours across Cloud but you have to pick up the right things and also uh yeah I'm I'm happy to do that uh basically no not much problem but I need to do exercise my daughter told me

Nicola Tangan: 您在中国农村长大,对吗?在宁德。

View/Hide Original English

more you grew up in a rural China right in uh ning

曾毓群: 是的。

View/Hide Original English

yes

Nicola Tangan: 您认为这对您个人有什么影响?从农村走向成功,这对您的事业有什么帮助?

View/Hide Original English

what um what do you think that has done to you as a person to come from a rural Place moving being very successful how has it helped you in your business

曾毓群: 我们当时经济非常困难,我的家乡也很贫穷。所以对我来说,从第一天起,我就认为我们有信心,因为我们相信一旦有机会,就能克服所有困难。

View/Hide Original English

we have uh very difficult economics and my hometown is very poor so uh for me is in the day one I think uh we are we have confidence uh because we believe we can overcome all the difficulties once we have a chance

曾毓群: 第二点是,我们有非常坚强的意志,我们不容易被打败,因为我们有经验。第三点是,我们不太看重财富,因为我们经历过贫困,所以我们对此没有问题。

View/Hide Original English

number two is we we we have a very strong mind we are not easy to be you know bat anywhere because we have experience number three is we are not much too much looking at the the wealth is because we have experienc so poor and we are we have no problem on that

曾毓群: 所以我们说,如果人们几乎都告诉我,曾总,你为什么不享受生活呢?你可以买游艇什么的。我说,对我来说,那没有多少乐趣。我们必须克服困难,做一些伟大的事情来支持穷人,支持世界上的可再生能源。他会非常高兴。

View/Hide Original English

so uh we we say that if people almost told me say Robin why don't you enjoy your life life you know you can buy a yard and know say for me is there is a not much joy you know we have to overcome the difficulties to do something great to to support people poor people and also support the Le renewable energy in the in the world he would be very happy

曾毓群: 所以我通常喜欢在相对贫困的地区投资建厂。

View/Hide Original English

so uh usually I uh I like to invest the the the manufacturing plant in the in the related poor area

Nicola Tangan: 您支持什么样的项目?

View/Hide Original English

what kind of projects to your support

曾毓群: 我的捐赠通常会给那些非常贫困的孩子。我们捐一些钱给他们,让他们有人照顾,有人陪伴,或者一起玩耍。所以我加入了一些国际儿童项目。

View/Hide Original English

for my donation is usually go to this very very poor the children we donate some money for them to like have some people to care just talk touch or you know play together so I join some uh uh uh international program for the children

曾毓群: 我相信如果我们能在一些贫困地区投资建厂,他们的家人就不需要搬到大城市工作,把孩子留在老家。这就是为什么我们在贵州、湖南等所有这些地区投资建厂来帮助他们。对我来说,这样的事情让我更快乐,也让我更强大。

View/Hide Original English

I believe if we can um C can invest the manufacturing PL in some poor area so their family no need to move out to come come out to the you know uh big city to work to leave the children in the hometown so that's why we invest the the manufacturing place in guo and man in h all these areas to help them so such kind of things is for me is much happier and may me more stronger in the in the in the rural area

对年轻人的建议

Nicola Tangan: 当您遇到中国年轻人时,您会给他们什么建议?

View/Hide Original English

when you meet young Chinese people what advice do you give them

曾毓群: 我的建议是:要有耐心,努力奋斗,因为你们有机会。

View/Hide Original English

my advice is uh be patient strive because you have your chance

Nicola Tangan: 如果您要给欧洲和美国的年轻人提建议,您会告诉他们什么?

View/Hide Original English

if you were to give advice to young people in Europe and the US what would you tell them

曾毓群: 我认为这很相似。通常今天的年轻人想很快变得富有,对吧?所以,要有耐心,但要努力奋斗。每个人都有机会,我相信。

View/Hide Original English

I think is similar usually today's young kids want to have be become rich very fast right so be patient but strive everyone have a chance I believe

Nicola Tangan: 曾总,能和您交谈真是太棒了。您所取得的成就令人难以置信,我不得不说,我很高兴我不是您的竞争对手。非常感谢。

View/Hide Original English

Robin it's been uh a tremendous talking to you it's incredible what you have achieved and I have to say I am uh I am pretty happy I'm uh not your competitor thanks a million oh

📌 文中提及的人物和组织

人物: Nicola Tangan

公司/组织: CATL, Norges Bank Investment Management, Tesla

产品/模型: Model 3, Model Y