从森林卫士到股东红利:加拿大林业模式的资本化转型
加拿大的森林管理在过去半个世纪中经历了翻天覆地的变化,这种转变本质上是从“与土地共生”向“资本驱动”的倒退。以 Suzanne Simard 的家族历史为例,其祖辈曾是在不列颠哥伦比亚省内陆雨林中进行选择性采伐(Selective Logging: 仅采伐特定成熟树木,保留森林结构完整性的方式)的马力伐木工(Horse Loggers)。然而,到了 20 世纪 60 年代,随着林业公司化浪潮席卷加拿大,这种小规模、注重生态平衡的生计方式被剥夺了经营许可。
林业公司化(Corporatisation of Forestry: 将森林资源交给追求短期经济效益的大型企业管理)彻底改变了人与森林的关系。管理权从生活在土地上的居民手中转移到了远在天边的股东手中。股东们唯一的预期是利息红利,一旦利益受损,他们会毫不犹豫地撤资并关闭林场。为了追求极端效率,资本驱动的林业转向了清场式砍伐(Clearcutting: 将特定区域内的树木全部砍伐的作业方式),试图将原始森林转化为所谓的“正规森林”(Normal Forests)。这种模式追求物种单一化、规格标准化,以便于未来的机械化采伐,但其代价是森林生产力的下降和生态健康的崩溃,甚至在海达瓜依(Haida Gwaii)等地区,出现了用不属于当地生态系统的松树强行替换百年雪松的怪象。
Original English Source
So let me give an example from my own family. So I come from a family of horse loggers... selective loggers. And by the 1960s basically had lost all of our permissions to to do that, we lost our livelihoods... as the corporatisation of forestry took its grip. It was no longer people living on the land with the forest and ensuring that their livelihoods were supported by the forest. It became more about people distant from the forest, you know, shareholders who expected dividends... And so it just changed from us doing it to something else, doing it. And, and we see the consequences now on our landscapes. We've seen extensive clearcutting. We've seen forests that are not nearly as productive as and healthy as the old forests that they that they've replaced... We've been on this mission since, for the last century to liquidate the old growth forests... The primary forests. And when Europeans came to Canada and set up the forestry industry, they said, we're going to convert these old forests to what they called normal forests. These European forests like tree farms, so that they're all like the same species, same size, more efficient for, you know, growing and then harvesting in the future, got to get rid of the old forest and so on.
单一造林的生态代价:从“杀手森林”到碳排放炸弹的连锁反应
这种工业化的造林模式直接导致了生态系统的脆弱化,甚至创造了极具破坏性的杀手森林(Killer Forest: 具有极高火灾隐患的人造单一林分)。在欧洲和南美,为了追求生长速度而大量种植的桉树,因其极度耗水且富含易燃油脂,被形容为“莫洛托夫鸡尾酒”般的易燃体。加拿大虽然没有大面积种植桉树,但林业部门为了市场价值,长期专注于补植针叶树(Conifers),如扭叶松、花旗松和云杉。为了确保这些商品树种的生长,管理部门甚至喷洒除草剂来清除落叶树种(如白杨和桦树),从而人为地创造了紧密、干燥且极度易燃的纯针叶林场。
这种错误的干预在火灾风险三角(Fire Risk Triangle: 由可燃物、点火源和气候条件构成的森林火灾风险模型)的每个维度上都加剧了危机。首先,由于 19 世纪末《印第安法案》禁止了原住民维持了数千年的原住民烧荒(Indigenous Burning: 传统的小规模可控焚烧,用以减少地面枯枝落叶蓄积),导致林床燃料大量堆积。其次,气候变暖增加了雷击起火。最严重的是,加拿大的森林自 2001 年起已从碳汇(Carbon Sink: 吸收并储存大气中二氧化碳的系统)转变为碳源(Carbon Source: 向大气释放二氧化碳的系统)。当前的清场采伐模式不仅损失了地上生物量的碳储量,更通过大规模的“全树采伐”严重扰乱了历经万年形成的森林地表。研究显示,由于重型机械作业和焚烧伐区残余物,当地损失了高达 61% 的地表有机碳,这无异于引爆了一枚无声的碳弹。
Original English Source
There's a term I learned from this book... we have to recognize we've created a killer forest... eucalyptus is a species that's been planted worldwide because it's one of the fastest growing species... But the reason it's a killer forest is because for one, it requires a lot of water... it draws down the hydrologic system, dries out the ecosystem. And then the, the, the tree itself is full of oils that are very flammable and it sheds bark... they're kind of like Molotov cocktails in a way... In Canada... we've at least where I'm from in British Columbia, we planted a lot of lodgepole pine and a lot of Douglas fir and a lot of spruce conifers. We've been focussed on conifers. Why? It's because... the conifers that brought such great market value... focus so much on these coniferous trees and then spraying herbicides and weeding out these other plants that really increase the flammability of the forest... we banned indigenous burning in the late 1880s with the Indian Act that's created havoc across the ecosystems... You wrote in the book that Canada's forest practices are detonating a carbon bomb. Yeah... In 2001, Canada's forests shifted from being a carbon sink overall to a carbon source... our experiments show that we're losing 61% of the forest floor carbon due to these practices. And it took a long time to get that forest floor... we estimate 10,000 years.
重塑森林弹性:母亲树项目与基于生态位的系统修复
面对崩塌的森林生态,Simard 提出了以母亲树项目(Mother Tree Project: 一项跨越 1000 公里气候梯度的长期林业实验)为核心的自救方案。该实验通过对比 0%、10%、30% 到 60% 等不同程度的保留密度,研究如何通过保留森林中的老龄树(母亲树)来保护碳库、维护生物多样性并增强森林的再生能力。实验证明,老树不仅是种子源,更通过地下网络为幼苗提供关键的营养与水分支持。特别是在干旱或严霜等压力环境下,保留较高比例的老树覆盖能显著提升森林的抗逆性。
要将森林重新转化为碳汇,Simard 勾勒出了一份清晰的路线图。首先,必须彻底改变采伐方式,实施更加精细的选择性采伐,根据特定的气候条件(Place Matters)因地制宜。其次,需要主动削减林地可燃物载量,鼓励落叶阔叶树种回归,因为它们具有天然的防火屏障作用。更关键的是,应当重新引入原住民的传统用火智慧。最后,Simard 强调,森林修复不能孤立进行,必须同步解决气候变化这一根本问题,坚定地从化石燃料转向可再生能源。只有在降低大气整体热量的基础上,森林的系统性修复才能真正发挥缓解生态危机的效能。
Original English Source
Let's talk about the Mother Tree project... it's a climate gradient experiment. It's 1000km long... we're trying different ways of leaving mother trees behind in different densities and configurations to protect, hopefully to protect the carbon pools and the biodiversity of the forests, and to increase the regenerative capacity of the forest... we need to leave these old trees behind... how much you leave behind depends on the climatic conditions of the forest... the more stressed a forest is under... especially benefit from a higher cover of these old trees... Can we get back to being a carbon sink? What does that roadmap look like? Yes we can... we really need to be tending our forests, you know, by, by reducing the fuel loads and encouraging these less flammable plants to come back, we need to reintroduce indigenous burning... preventing wildfire is really important... We also have to deal with climate change, right? That's the big elephant in the room. And we need to be getting off of fossil fuels.
📌 文中提及的人物和组织
媒体/书籍: When the Forest Breathes